All High Courts

Patna HC Quashes Solo Order By Minorities Panel Member On BPSC

Patna HC Quashes Solo Order By Minorities Panel Member On BPSC
Patna HC Quashes Solo Order By Minorities Panel Member On BPSC

The Patna High Court has ruled that a single member of the Bihar State Minorities Commission cannot pass binding orders or directions in the Commission's name without its formal approval. The court struck down a directive issued by a Commission member instructing the Bihar Public Service Commission (BPSC) to consider a candidate for appointment as Assistant Professor in Physics.

A Single Judge Bench of Justice Rajesh Kumar Verma ruled that the order passed by Md. Shamshad Alam, a member of the Bihar State Minorities Commission, acting on his own and without the Chairman's consent, violated the provisions of the Bihar State Minorities Commission Act, 1991.

How The Dispute Over The Assistant Professor Post Arose

The matter traced back to Advertisement No. 26 of 1999, floated by BPSC to fill five posts of Assistant Professor (Physics) in state engineering colleges. Respondent No. 3, one of the applicants, cleared the screening test held in February 2002 and sat for an interview in September 2002.

He was not recommended for appointment because of his merit position — BPSC noted he had scored 96.04 marks, while another candidate had secured 99.86 marks.

The situation shifted when an appointment made against a reserved-category seat was cancelled in May 2006 after the selected candidate did not join. Respondent No. 3 then sought to be considered against this vacant post and moved the High Court through CWJC No. 8411 of 2007.

On March 13, 2012, the court disposed of that plea, directing him to file a representation before the relevant government authority. When this representation was turned down, he challenged the rejection before the High Court and, in May 2013, also approached the Bihar State Minorities Commission seeking intervention regarding the vacant post.

The Commission Member's Unilateral Direction

After the Commission issued a notice flagging possible discrimination against a minority candidate in the selection process, its member Md. Shamshad Alam went a step further. On December 30, 2013, he directed BPSC to decide on and recommend the candidate's name to the Science and Technology Department for appointment.

BPSC challenged this direction before the High Court, asserting its status as an autonomous constitutional authority under Article 315 of the Constitution and arguing that the Minorities Commission had no power to dictate outcomes in public recruitment. It further contended that the Commission's role was purely recommendatory and it could not act as a superior adjudicatory body over appointment matters.

Notably, the Bihar State Minorities Commission itself distanced itself from the disputed order. In its counter-affidavit, the Commission clarified that Md. Shamshad Alam had issued the direction in his personal capacity, on his own letterhead, without securing approval from either the Commission or its Chairman.

What The High Court Held

Reviewing these submissions, Justice Verma found that the Commission member had opened proceedings and passed the order entirely on his own, without any sanctioned authority to do so. The court observed:

“Having heard learned counsel for the parties and the stand taken by the Bihar State Minorities Commission in the counter affidavit, it transpire that the letter issued by the Minorities Commission by Md. Shamshad Alam (Advocate) in his individual capacity and without the consent of the Chairman of the Minorities Commission and the file in question opened by the learned Member in his individual capacity which is against the settled law of Minorities Commission Act, 1991.”

The court further noted that Section 8 of the 1991 Act bars the Commission from probing matters already pending before any court, tribunal, or quasi-judicial body — reinforcing that the member's intervention exceeded the Commission's legal mandate.

The bench added that Md. Shamshad Alam held “not been vested with any power or authority to issue such order or direction on his behalf being member of the Commission or on behalf of the Commission,” and recorded that even the Commission itself was not backing the order under challenge.

Outcome

Concluding that the Commission member lacked the authority to issue such directions either individually or on the Commission's behalf, the Patna High Court allowed BPSC's writ petition and set aside the order dated December 30, 2013.

Case: Bihar Public Service Commission Through its Secretary vs Bihar State Minorities Commission through Its Chairman & Ors.
Counsel for Applicant: Senior Adv. K.K. Jha, Adv. Anish Kumar
Counsel for Opposite Party: Adv. Md. Nadim Seraj
Order Date: 2026-11-02
Read Order:

Related Reads

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward