All High Courts

"Acted As A Superpower Authority": Gujarat HC Fines Collector ₹1L

"Acted As A Superpower Authority": Gujarat HC Fines Collector ₹1L
"Acted As A Superpower Authority": Gujarat HC Fines Collector ₹1L

The Gujarat High Court has ordered the Ahmedabad Collector to personally bear ₹1 lakh in costs from his own salary for defying an earlier judicial directive in a land conversion dispute.

Justice MK Thakker passed the order while hearing a plea from a woman landowner whose application to convert her agricultural land for non-agricultural use had been rejected by the Collector for the second time, despite a prior High Court ruling instructing him to reconsider the matter.

The case is titled Bhumikaben v Collector, Ahmedabad & Anr.

Why The Court Took Exception To The Collector's Conduct

Justice Thakker observed that the Collector had once again rejected the woman's application on grounds the Court had already declared unsustainable in its earlier judgment.

Expressing displeasure at the repeated disregard for judicial authority, the Court remarked that "this is not the first instance where the Collector has acted as a superpower authority and considering himself as a person, who can act according to his own whims and wish."

It added that "every person is required to respect and obey the orders of the Court with due dignity for the institution," and that government departments enjoy no exemption from this obligation.

The Bench further held that the litigant's hardship, caused solely by the Collector's conduct in forcing her to return to court repeatedly, had to be personally compensated by him and not the public exchequer.

The Land Conversion Dispute

The petitioner had originally sought permission under Section 65 of the Gujarat Land Revenue Code, 1879, which deals with converting agricultural land for non-agricultural purposes.

In February 2025, the Collector rejected her plea, raising objections over earlier land transactions and citing the absence of clearance under Section 63 of the Gujarat Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, which restricts transfers of agricultural land to non-agriculturists without prior sanction.

She challenged this rejection before the High Court, which quashed the Collector's order on March 2, 2026, and asked her to file a fresh application, directing the Collector to decide it within the statutory timeframe.

That earlier ruling had clarified that under Section 65 proceedings, the Collector's scrutiny is confined to verifying whether the applicant occupies the land and whether it is held or assessed for agricultural use — and cannot extend to examining title disputes or the validity of past land dealings.

Despite this, when the petitioner filed a fresh application in April 2026, the Collector rejected it yet again on August 6, relying on adverse opinions from the Mamlatdar, the Agricultural Lands Tribunal, and the Deputy Collector (Land Reforms), while once more referencing the earlier land transactions.

He also pointed to the State government's intention to challenge the March 2 judgment in appeal. However, the High Court noted in its November 5 judgment that no such appeal had actually been filed.

What The November 5 Order Directs

The Court held that authorities cannot simply disregard judicial directions and act as they please. It also flagged that the Collector had failed to decide the fresh application within the prescribed statutory period.

Government departments, the Court said, must either comply with court orders or promptly seek judicial recourse if genuine difficulties arise in implementation.

It observed: "Where the Government departments neither obeys the order nor approach to the Court in time, then only possible inference in law is that such party disobeys the order of the Court... Flagrant violation of the Court's order would reflect the attitude of the officer concerned to undermine the authority of the Courts, its dignity and the administration of justice."

Consequently, the Court quashed the Collector's August 6 rejection and restored the woman's application for reconsideration in line with its earlier judgment.

It directed the Collector to deposit ₹1 lakh with the High Court Registry within one month, to be paid from his own salary. The order further specified that should the Collector fail to make the payment, the State government must deposit the amount on his behalf and subsequently recover it from his salary.

The Court also instructed that the sum be transferred electronically to the petitioner once verified.

Advocates Sunil S Joshi and Amit M Lashwani represented the petitioner, while Additional Government Pleader Jay Trivedi appeared for the Collector and the State.

Case: Bhumikaben v Collector, Ahmedabad & Anr.
Counsel for Applicant: Adv. Sunil S Joshi, Adv. Amit M Lashwani
Counsel for Opposite Party: Additional Government Pleader Jay Trivedi
Order Date: 2026-11-05
Read Order:

Related Reads

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward