All High Courts

J&K&L HC Dismisses Dharmarth Trust's Recall Plea Over Death

J&K&L HC Dismisses Dharmarth Trust's Recall Plea Over Death
J&K&L HC Dismisses Dharmarth Trust's Recall Plea Over Death

The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has refused to recall a judgment delivered against the J&K Dharmarth Trust, ruling that the death of a respondent proceeded against ex parte does not by itself render the verdict a nullity, especially when an appellate remedy remained open to the aggrieved party.

Justice M.A. Chowdhary dismissed the Trust's application, holding that it had failed to inform the Court of the respondent's death during the pendency of the writ petition and could not now use a recall application as a substitute for an appeal or review.

Background Of The Dispute

The Trust had moved the application seeking recall of the High Court's judgment dated December 19, 2025, which was passed in a writ petition challenging an order of the J&K Industrial Tribunal. The Tribunal had awarded former employee Chand Ram entitlement to 50% back wages from the date of his termination until the award was passed, payable by the Dharmarth Trust.

Seeking recall, the Trust argued that Chand Ram had died while the writ petition was pending and that his legal representatives were never brought on record, causing the proceedings to abate. It contended the resulting judgment was non est in law.

The Trust also claimed that since Chand Ram had been proceeded against ex parte, the key issue of whether the Trust qualified as an "industry" was never properly argued. It further alleged that the judgment had been reserved and pronounced months later without adequate hearing or updates, pointing to an alleged jurisdictional defect that it said made the recall application maintainable even without a review petition.

Why The Court Rejected The Recall Plea

Examining the procedural record, the High Court noted that Chand Ram had initially appeared through Advocate Raghu Mehta but was later proceeded against ex parte due to continued absence. Crucially, the Court found that the Trust never brought his death to its attention at any point before the writ petition was finally decided.

Had the Trust done so, the Court observed, it could have taken steps to implead Chand Ram's legal heirs. Since no such effort was made, the Trust could not now invoke its own omission as grounds to unsettle the judgment.

The Court was unambiguous that the Trust had sought to raise the death issue only after the judgment went against it, which it found impermissible. It held that an aggrieved litigant in such a situation has defined remedies — an appeal, or a review if there was an error apparent on the face of the record — and cannot bypass both through a recall application.

Addressing the argument that the judgment was rendered void because it was passed after Chand Ram's death, the Court held that this fact, even if true, did not strip the judgment of validity. It observed that the Trust "was well within its rights to file the appeal against legal heirs of the respondent no. 2," even if the judgment had been passed after his demise.

Instead of pursuing that course, the Court noted, the Trust opted for the recall route, which it found legally untenable given the availability of an appeal.

Allegations Against Court's Functioning Rejected

The High Court also took strong note of the Trust's claim that the judgment had been reserved and delivered after several months without proper hearing or updation. Referring to the judgment itself, the Court pointed out that the matter was reserved on December 4, 2025 and pronounced on December 19, 2025 — a gap of only 15 days.

Calling this allegation factually baseless, the Court observed that it unfairly cast aspersions on the functioning of the institution.

The Court further flagged a concern regarding the conduct of the advocate who drafted the recall application, noting that this advocate was the brother and chamber-mate of the counsel who had originally appeared in the matter. While the Court chose not to pursue the matter further, it left it to the advocate concerned to reflect on his professional responsibilities.

Outcome

Concluding that the Trust had pursued an impermissible legal route despite having both appeal and review options available, the High Court dismissed the recall application, describing it as "grossly misconceived." The original judgment upholding the Industrial Tribunal's award in favour of Chand Ram was left undisturbed.

Case: Dharmarth Trust J and K vs Industrial Tribunal & Anr.
Counsel for Applicant: Adv. R. S. Thakur, Sr. Advocate, with Adv. Arun Singh
Counsel for Opposite Party: Adv. Raghu Mehta
Order Date: 2026-11-04
Read Order:

Related Reads

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward