by-nishtha

SC Registers Writ Plea Over Kerala Congress's Social Media Post Against CJI Surya Kant

SC Registers Writ Plea Over Kerala Congress's Social Media Post Against CJI Surya Kant
SC Registers Writ Plea Over Kerala Congress's Social Media Post Against CJI Surya Kant

A letter demanding contempt proceedings against the Kerala Pradesh Congress Committee for a social media post targeting Chief Justice of India Surya Kant has now been converted into a formal writ petition by the Supreme Court.

Advocate Vineet Jindal had addressed the letter directly to the CJI on October 13. The registry subsequently registered it as a civil writ petition on October 30, though no bench has yet been assigned to hear the matter.

The controversy stems from a post shared on the official X account of Congress Kerala on October 12. The message read: "Dear Surya Kant, If law and order is not your domain, resign now. We will find your replacement who can handle it." The post was taken down shortly after it was published.

In his correspondence, Jindal argued that the position held by the CJI cannot be made contingent upon the goodwill or disapproval of any political outfit. He contended that the post raised a serious question — whether it fell within the limits of legitimate political commentary or crossed into territory warranting scrutiny under criminal contempt law.

Beyond the social media post, the letter also drew attention to a political gathering near the Supreme Court premises on October 12, which reportedly included Congress leader Rahul Gandhi and other opposition figures. Jindal urged an inquiry into whether any restricted zone was breached or security norms violated during the demonstration.

He was careful to clarify, however, that a peaceful protest, political sloganeering at a lawful venue, or the mere presence of political figures near the court does not automatically amount to contempt or any other legal violation.

To ensure any probe is grounded in solid evidence, Jindal requested that authorities preserve CCTV recordings, entry-control logs, and security deployment details, cautioning against reliance on unverified reports or selectively shared accounts of the incident.

This latest development follows an unconditional apology issued by the KPCC to the CJI. Responding to a legal notice from Meenesh Dubey, Joint Secretary of the Supreme Court Bar Association, KPCC President Sunny Joseph clarified in a reply dated October 22 that the objectionable post was put up by party functionary Vijay Thottathil without any authorization from the party's leadership. Thottathil has since been stripped of his position within the party.

In a related development, a bench comprising CJI Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi had, on October 15, issued notice to the Congress party, Rahul Gandhi, and other INDIA bloc leaders in connection with a separate petition filed by four advocates over the October 12 march. That petition had also sought contempt action concerning the Kerala Congress post, but the bench chose not to issue notice on that specific prayer.

"No contempt today. We are only issuing notice. Let us see what the response is, and then we will take it forward," the CJI remarked during the hearing.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet
SC Registers Writ Plea Over Kerala Congress's Social Media Post Against CJI Surya Kant

A letter demanding contempt proceedings against the Kerala Pradesh Congress Committee for a social media post targeting Chief Justice of India Surya Kant has now been converted into a formal writ petition by the Supreme Court.

Advocate Vineet Jindal had addressed the letter directly to the CJI on October 13. The registry subsequently registered it as a civil writ petition on October 30, though no bench has yet been assigned to hear the matter.

The controversy stems from a post shared on the official X account of Congress Kerala on October 12. The message read: "Dear Surya Kant, If law and order is not your domain, resign now. We will find your replacement who can handle it." The post was taken down shortly after it was published.

In his correspondence, Jindal argued that the position held by the CJI cannot be made contingent upon the goodwill or disapproval of any political outfit. He contended that the post raised a serious question — whether it fell within the limits of legitimate political commentary or crossed into territory warranting scrutiny under criminal contempt law.

Beyond the social media post, the letter also drew attention to a political gathering near the Supreme Court premises on October 12, which reportedly included Congress leader Rahul Gandhi and other opposition figures. Jindal urged an inquiry into whether any restricted zone was breached or security norms violated during the demonstration.

He was careful to clarify, however, that a peaceful protest, political sloganeering at a lawful venue, or the mere presence of political figures near the court does not automatically amount to contempt or any other legal violation.

To ensure any probe is grounded in solid evidence, Jindal requested that authorities preserve CCTV recordings, entry-control logs, and security deployment details, cautioning against reliance on unverified reports or selectively shared accounts of the incident.

This latest development follows an unconditional apology issued by the KPCC to the CJI. Responding to a legal notice from Meenesh Dubey, Joint Secretary of the Supreme Court Bar Association, KPCC President Sunny Joseph clarified in a reply dated October 22 that the objectionable post was put up by party functionary Vijay Thottathil without any authorization from the party's leadership. Thottathil has since been stripped of his position within the party.

In a related development, a bench comprising CJI Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi had, on October 15, issued notice to the Congress party, Rahul Gandhi, and other INDIA bloc leaders in connection with a separate petition filed by four advocates over the October 12 march. That petition had also sought contempt action concerning the Kerala Congress post, but the bench chose not to issue notice on that specific prayer.

"No contempt today. We are only issuing notice. Let us see what the response is, and then we will take it forward," the CJI remarked during the hearing.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward