by-nishtha

When Is Street Protest the Court's Business? The Record Suggests It Depends on Who Is Chief Justice

When Is Street Protest the Court's Business? The Record Suggests It Depends on Who Is Chief Justice
When Is Street Protest the Court's Business? The Record Suggests It Depends on Who Is Chief Justice

When reporters pressed Chief Justice of India Surya Kant on 12 October 2026 about demonstrations seeking the removal of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, his answer was brief: "This is a law-and-order issue. It is not my domain." The remark drew a sharp line between policing, which belongs to the executive, and the constitutional limits on policing, which the Supreme Court has long claimed as its own. A look at the Chief Justice's own bench from that same week suggests the line is not as clean as he made it sound.

Just three days before that statement, on 9 October, a bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant along with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana had directed the Centre not to completely suspend train and Metro services into Delhi. The bench went further, noting that "it's high time that some suitable place where all basic amenities can be provided for peaceful and lawful protestors needs to be identified and designated."

A court that intervenes in Metro operations and floats a plan to relocate demonstrators is, in substance, regulating public order — it simply confined itself to logistics rather than legality. That omission matters because, even as the bench was deliberating transport arrangements, the state's response to the protests was hardening.

The Measures Left Unreviewed

Prohibitory orders under Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) were already in force. Protesters were being detained at Jantar Mantar. Then, on 12 October, Delhi Police de-notified Jantar Mantar as a protest site altogether, shifting permitted dissent to Ramlila Ground, Burari and East Delhi.

Prohibitory orders, detentions and the scrapping of a historic protest venue are precisely the kind of state action that courts are meant to test for proportionality. The Supreme Court's own precedents make this explicit.

No Law-and-Order Exemption from Article 32

In In Re: Ramlila Maidan Incident (2012), which examined the midnight police crackdown on Baba Ramdev's followers, the Court declared that "citizens have a fundamental right to assembly and peaceful protest which cannot be taken away by an arbitrary executive or legislative action." The phrase "arbitrary executive action" places police conduct inside judicial scrutiny, not beyond it.

Six years on, the Court extended that logic to the very location now stripped of protest status. In Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. Union of India (2018), it rejected a blanket ban on demonstrations at Jantar Mantar, holding that even genuine hardship to nearby residents could not justify eliminating protest entirely, and that authorities must instead "adopt such measures … so that there is a balancing of the rights of both the sections of the society." The Court struck that balance itself rather than leaving it to police discretion.

Two years later, Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India (2020) set out the test that every prohibitory order must satisfy: "The power under Section 144, Cr.P.C cannot be used to suppress legitimate expression of opinion or grievance or exercise of any democratic rights." The bench — Justices N.V. Ramana, R. Subhash Reddy and B.R. Gavai — added that repeated orders amount to an abuse of power and must be published so they can be legally challenged. Since Section 163 of the BNSS mirrors the old Section 144, Bhasin applies directly to the Delhi orders of October 2026 — and only a court can determine whether those orders meet the standard.

A Pattern That Tracks the Chief Justice, Not the Law

Reviewing two decades of Supreme Court interventions in street protest and public-order cases reveals two distinct patterns, and which one prevails appears to depend heavily on who occupies the Chief Justice's chair.

In 2026, under Chief Justice Surya Kant, the Court regulated Metro suspensions and floated a relocation idea during the anti-CEC protests, but left the Section 163 orders unexamined while Jantar Mantar was de-notified.

In 2024, under Chief Justice Sanjiv Khanna (with Justices Gavai and Viswanathan), the Court responded to "bulldozer" demolitions with pan-India guidelines backed by contempt powers, mandating notice and videography — though enforcement has remained patchy.

In 2023, Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud's bench, confronting the Manipur violence, described a "complete breakdown" of state machinery, summoned the Director General of Police, and set up court-monitored oversight of investigations — though only after a three-month delay.

In 2021, under Chief Justice N.V. Ramana, the Court took suo motu notice of the Lakhimpur Kheri killings and questioned why a minister's son had not been arrested; an arrest followed the very next day, and bail was later cancelled.

Also in 2021, during the farmers' tractor rally dispute, Chief Justice S.A. Bobde's bench declared, "We are not the first authority," leaving the matter entirely to Delhi Police.

In 2020, the same Chief Justice, ruling on the Shaheen Bagh sit-in (Amit Sahni), held that dissent must occur only in "designated places" — a formula that would later serve as a template for relocating protests.

That same year, confronted with the North-East Delhi riots, Chief Justice Bobde's bench said, "We cannot give preventive reliefs," and pushed the matter to the High Court for a quicker hearing.

In 2019, facing police action on the Jamia Millia Islamia and Aligarh Muslim University campuses, the Bobde-led Court said, "Let the rioting stop," and redirected petitioners to the High Courts rather than ordering a Supreme Court-monitored inquiry.

In 2018, Chief Justice Dipak Misra's bench issued preventive, remedial and punitive directions on mob lynching (Tehseen Poonawalla), though a central anti-lynching law never materialised and compliance was chased for years. The same year, the same Chief Justice struck down the blanket ban on protest at Jantar Mantar in the MKSS case — a site that would remain open until it was de-notified in October 2026.

Going back further, in 2012, under Chief Justice S.H. Kapadia, the Court found the Ramlila Maidan police action excessive and affirmed the right to protest, though it docked compensation for what it called "contributory negligence" by organisers.

And in 2006, Chief Justice Y.K. Sabharwal's bench issued seven binding directions on police reform (Prakash Singh) — directions that, fifteen years later, no state has fully implemented.

The pattern that emerges is stark: whenever the Court engaged directly, the state altered its conduct within days. Whenever it stepped back, the very authority being challenged was left to judge its own actions.

Notably, Chief Justice Surya Kant has personally sat on both sides of this divide — as part of Chief Justice Bobde's bench that professed helplessness during the Delhi riots, and later as part of Chief Justice Ramana's bench that forced swift action in Lakhimpur Kheri. He is, therefore, no stranger to which judicial posture actually protects rights on the ground.

The Deference Line, Traced

The pattern of judicial restraint began by conditioning relief on the conduct of the aggrieved. On 16 December 2019, after police entered the Jamia Millia Islamia campus, Chief Justice Bobde refused to hear student petitioners until the violence subsided, sending them to High Courts the following day — even though their grievance was about excessive police conduct, not their own.

That reluctance deepened during the Delhi riots of 2020. On 2 March 2020, as victims sought criminal cases against politicians over hate speech, the bench stated flatly that it "cannot stop things from happening" and "cannot give preventive reliefs" — a claim that sits oddly with the Court's long history of injunctions and habeas corpus relief, both forms of preventive intervention.

The farmers' tractor-rally episode in January 2021 offers a more balanced version of restraint: the Court refused the government's request for an injunction against the protest, telling the Attorney General "We are not the first authority." This kind of even-handed non-intervention preserves protest rights rather than curbing them — arguably close to what Chief Justice Surya Kant intended in his October 2026 remark. The trouble arises when restraint calcifies into a rule that systematically favours restriction, as happened with Shaheen Bagh.

Amit Sahni v. Commissioner of Police (2020) converted that restraint into formal doctrine, holding that "public ways and public spaces cannot be occupied in such a manner and that too indefinitely" and that dissent must occur in "designated places alone." The judgment never clarified who gets to designate such places or what standards they must meet. October 2026 has now answered both questions — Delhi Police designated the replacement sites unilaterally — and the answer should give the Court pause, since MKSS itself had warned that Ramlila Maidan "has its own limitations" as a substitute protest venue.

The Other Line: When the Court Acted

Contrasting sharply with this reluctance, several episodes show the Court treating law and order as squarely within its constitutional remit.

In Tehseen S. Poonawalla v. Union of India (2018), Chief Justice Dipak Misra's bench condemned mob violence in forceful terms: "The horrendous acts of mobocracy cannot be permitted to inundate the law of the land." It ordered states to treat prevention of vigilante violence as both their legal duty and the Court's abiding concern — though the case suffered from weak follow-up over subsequent years.

Lakhimpur Kheri demonstrates what sustained judicial attention can achieve. On 8 October 2021, Chief Justice Ramana's bench — joined by Justices Surya Kant and Hima Kohli — pointedly asked Uttar Pradesh what message it conveyed by merely serving notice on a murder suspect connected to a minister's family. Accused Ashish Mishra was arrested the very next day, and by April 2022 the same bench had cancelled his bail.

Even a delayed response produced results in Manipur. Though the Court had initially declined to urgently hear a challenge to internet shutdowns in July 2023, by 1 August Chief Justice Chandrachud's bench was asking whether there existed "a complete breakdown of law and order and constitutional machinery," and summoned the state's police chief in person. Within a week, a court-appointed panel was overseeing investigations.

The 2024 bulldozer-demolition judgment went furthest, proving that preventive judicial relief is entirely possible. Justices B.R. Gavai and K.V. Viswanathan held that "if the executive acts as a judge and inflicts penalty of demolition on the citizen on the ground that he is an accused, it violates the principle of separation of powers," and mandated 15 days' notice, videography of demolitions, and personal accountability for officials, enforceable through contempt proceedings — directly contradicting the 2020 claim that courts cannot offer preventive relief.

The Problem of Enforcement

Even strong judgments lose force without sustained follow-up. Anuradha Bhasin required that internet shutdowns be published, time-bound and proportionate. Yet data compiled by Access Now shows that India averaged roughly 94 shutdowns annually in the six years following the ruling — marginally higher than the 88.5 per year recorded before it. The judgment's principles were sound, but review was delegated to an executive committee, and the Court never audited whether states complied.

Police reform tells a similar story. Twenty years after Prakash Singh, assessments by the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI) show that not a single state fully complies with the Court's 2006 directions meant to insulate police forces from political interference. Former Law Commission chairman Justice A.P. Shah has noted that the Court never pursued contempt proceedings against non-complying states. The practical consequence is a police force still beholden to the political executive — the same executive whose protests it now decides to permit or disperse.

What Remains Unsaid

Dismissing a protest crackdown as purely a "law-and-order issue" misstates the Court's jurisdiction. Ramlila Maidan, MKSS and Anuradha Bhasin all establish that while maintaining public order is an executive function, policing the limits of that function is a judicial one. History backs this distinction: when the Court engaged, outcomes shifted — an arrest within a day, a police chief hauled before the bench within a week, mandatory notice periods for bulldozers. Each of these results traces back to a Chief Justice willing to treat the street as the Court's legitimate concern.

What was needed from Chief Justice Surya Kant was a single clarifying line — that Section 163 orders remain subject to judicial review, and that this Court intends to review them. Until that sentence is spoken, the courtroom doors may stand open, but the street outside remains unguarded.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward