All High Courts

SFI-Linked Students Move Top Court After Kerala HC Reverses Order Allowing Them to Sit Semester Exams

SFI-Linked Students Move Top Court After Kerala HC Reverses Order Allowing Them to Sit Semester Exams
SFI-Linked Students Move Top Court After Kerala HC Reverses Order Allowing Them to Sit Semester Exams

Sixteen suspended students of the Sree Sankaracharya University of Sanskrit, Kalady, have knocked on the doors of the Supreme Court, challenging a Division Bench ruling of the Kerala High Court that overturned an earlier interim arrangement letting them write their semester examinations beginning November 4.

The petitioners, all associated with the Students Federation of India (SFI), want the apex court to revive the order a Single Judge had passed on October 30. That order had allowed them to attempt the exams while their writ petition against their suspension remained pending before the High Court.

Besides restoring that arrangement, the students have asked the Supreme Court to let them provisionally attempt the remaining papers and to direct the University to hold special examinations for any papers missed in the interim, once the apex court passes its own order.

Their core grievance is that the High Court's decision came on the eve of the exams, threatening them with the loss of an entire academic semester.

Background: Suspension After Campus Protest

The dispute traces back to a student protest on campus on August 13, following which the University suspended the 16 students on September 1, pending an enquiry. The students are enrolled across different programmes — MSW, MFA, MA, the Four-Year Undergraduate Programme (FYUGP), and PhD.

An enquiry committee was formed after a Syndicate decision on August 22. As part of the suspension, the students were also barred from campus premises except when required to appear before the enquiry panel.

Aggrieved by what they called a prolonged and open-ended suspension, the students approached the Kerala High Court on October 12, seeking quashing of the suspension order and provisional acceptance of their exam applications, among other reliefs.

With the enquiry still unfinished and exams drawing near, they filed an interim application. The Single Judge, on October 30, permitted them to sit for the examinations starting November 4, explicitly subject to the outcome of the main writ petition and clarifying that such permission would not confer any independent right or equitable claim.

University's Challenge and the Division Bench Order

The University contested this interim relief before a Division Bench, arguing that the students lacked the mandatory minimum attendance, had not cleared internal assessments, and had failed to complete examination registration within the prescribed timeline.

It further contended that the Single Judge had effectively granted the students the substantive relief sought in the writ petition itself — at the interim stage — without sufficient pleadings or evidence establishing their eligibility to appear for the exams.

The Division Bench, on November 3, agreed with the University and set aside the interim order. It observed that there was a "total lack of pleadings" on the students' part regarding their entitlement to sit the exams under the applicable regulations governing attendance and internal assessment.

Students' Case Before the Supreme Court

In their appeal to the Supreme Court, the students argue that the High Court overlooked a crucial fact — that any attendance shortfall stemmed directly from the University's own suspension order, which had barred them from attending classes in the first place.

They contend the University cannot be allowed to benefit from a predicament of its own making.

The petition also states that the University raised the attendance and internal-assessment objections for the first time at the writ appeal stage, denying the students a fair chance to respond before the Single Judge.

Additionally, the petitioners argue the Division Bench wrongly equated the interim relief with the final relief sought in the writ petition. They stress that their principal prayer is quashing of the suspension order itself, while permission to write exams was only an interim, conditional arrangement pending final adjudication.

They warn that the High Court's ruling has, in effect, shut the door on their academic prospects at the interlocutory stage itself, since the examinations will conclude well before the writ petition is finally heard.

FIR Controversy Cited

The Supreme Court petition also brings up two separate FIRs connected to the August 13 incident.

The first FIR, registered suo motu by Kalady Police on the night of the protest, reportedly made no mention of any mock cremation or physical assault on the Vice Chancellor, according to the petitioners.

A second FIR, registered on August 16, followed a complaint by the Vice Chancellor to the State Police Chief. The petitioners allege this second FIR introduced fresh allegations — including a mock cremation and physical assault on the Vice Chancellor — invoking non-bailable offences under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.

The students argue that a suspension pending enquiry cannot be allowed to function as a de facto punishment before any finding of guilt has been recorded.

The matter has been filed before the Supreme Court through Advocate-on-Record Subhash Chandran.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant: AOR Subhash Chandran
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward