All High Courts

Apex Court Refuses to Intervene in Rajasthan Cricket Body's Election Row, Tells Parties to Approach High Court

Apex Court Refuses to Intervene in Rajasthan Cricket Body's Election Row, Tells Parties to Approach High Court
Apex Court Refuses to Intervene in Rajasthan Cricket Body's Election Row, Tells Parties to Approach High Court

The Supreme Court on Wednesday steered clear of a dispute over internal elections, voter lists, and administrative conflicts within the Rajasthan Cricket Association (RCA), directing that all such grievances be resolved by the Rajasthan High Court instead.

The case, Rajendra Singh vs State of Rajasthan, came up before a Bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V Mohana.

The judges made it clear they saw no reason to step into proceedings already underway at the High Court, noting that constitutional courts at the state level are equally capable of handling such disputes without needing supervision from the top court.

Justice Bagchi was candid in his remarks during the hearing, saying the Court should not attempt to guess how the High Court will rule or what conclusions it might reach. He added that if the High Court does err, the Supreme Court remains available as a corrective forum, but emphasised that there was no need to "handhold" a court that is fully capable of deciding matters on its own.

The plea had been filed by Rajendra Singh Nandhu, who serves as Secretary of the Nagaur District Cricket Association, questioning how the RCA's election process had been carried out.

Representing the petitioner, counsel told the Bench that seven district cricket associations had been arbitrarily dissolved, which stripped them of their voting rights in the election.

It was further argued that several appeals lodged by the affected district bodies were still awaiting a decision. The petitioner's side pressed for appointment of an independent Ombudsman to resolve questions around who qualifies for membership, affiliation status, and voting eligibility before the election process could be treated as complete.

The Bench flagged that whether state-level cricket associations must strictly follow the judicial oversight framework recommended by the Justice Lodha Committee, or whether they instead fall under later laws passed by the legislature, is a legal question still open for debate.

Looking at the facts on record, the Court pointed out that the polls had been conducted under an administrator appointed by the Rajasthan High Court. This administrator had brought in a former State Chief Election Commissioner to act as the returning officer, who finalised the voter rolls after disposing of objections through detailed, reasoned orders.

The Bench also took into account that the election results had already been kept in a sealed cover, in line with an earlier Supreme Court order concerning the lack of women's representation in the association's electoral and governing structure.

Reaffirming the principle of judicial hierarchy, the apex court said it saw no justification for bypassing the High Court's authority while the matter was actively pending there.

The Bench expressed confidence that the Rajasthan High Court would give a fair hearing to every party involved and would pass suitable orders addressing each issue raised, including the complaints about excluded district associations and disputes over the voter list.

With these observations, the Supreme Court declined to intervene further, leaving all outstanding issues for the High Court to decide.

Case: Rajendra Singh vs State of Rajasthan
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward