All High Courts

Supreme Court Judge Flags Gender Skew in Collegium, Pitches for Woman Invitee

Supreme Court Judge Flags Gender Skew in Collegium, Pitches for Woman Invitee
Supreme Court Judge Flags Gender Skew in Collegium, Pitches for Woman Invitee

Supreme Court judge Justice Ujjal Bhuyan has said the apex court's Collegium system continues to be "male-dominated" and has pitched for inviting a woman judge to participate in its deliberations to make the process more inclusive.

He made these observations while delivering an address as Chief Guest at the 12th Convocation of the University of Science & Technology, Meghalaya.

Pointing to the composition of the top court, Justice Bhuyan noted that of the sanctioned strength of 35 judges, only three are women, a ratio he said fails to mirror the actual presence of women across the legal profession and judiciary nationwide.

Referring to recent appointments, he mentioned Justice Mohana's elevation from the Supreme Court Bar and Justice Sunita Agarwal's appointment as Chief Justice of the Gujarat High Court, while stressing that such instances remain exceptions rather than the norm.

"This is one aspect we need to look at seriously," he remarked, describing the current numbers as disproportionate to the scale of women's participation in law.

The judge also revisited a seminar he had attended in March last year, organised by women lawyers within the Supreme Court premises, which focused on the inadequate representation of women among senior advocates and as judges in constitutional courts.

At that forum, he recalled suggesting that since Collegiums tend to be male-dominated bodies, they should consider including a woman judge as an invitee during proceedings — a step he believes would bring in a perspective closer to ground realities at the Bar.

"This will give a better representation of the situation at the Bar. But it is indeed a great pride to see women doing exceptionally well," he said.

Justice Bhuyan further took up the issue of why strong performance by women in the legal field does not translate into a proportionate number of senior designations. He attributed this gap largely to the subjective nature of selection criteria used in such processes.

He recalled telling the earlier conference that his own research indicated that wherever selection is based on objective parameters, women's representation rises significantly.

Citing figures, he said that in judicial services in Assam, Meghalaya, Rajasthan, Maharashtra, and Telangana, entry-level recruitment at the Grade III judicial service stage shows women's representation crossing 50%, with Assam recording as high as 65%.

At the Grade II, Chief Judicial Magistrate level, he said, women's representation stands at around 45%.

However, he pointed out that this proportion steadily declines as one moves up the judicial hierarchy toward Grade I positions, such as judgeships in High Courts or the Supreme Court, where representation falls to roughly 25-30%.

He attributed this sharper drop to the shift from objective, merit-based testing to a more subjective, recommendation-driven process through the Collegium mechanism, which he said disproportionately affects women candidates.

Reflecting on his own tenure, Justice Bhuyan noted that Justice B.V. Nagarathna had been his sole woman colleague on the Supreme Court bench, underscoring the continuing gender imbalance at the highest levels of the judiciary despite a growing pool of qualified women lawyers and judicial officers across the country.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward