by-nishtha

Supreme Court Revives Disproportionate Assets Case, Says Tax Circulars on Gold Limits Can't Substitute Proof of Income Source

Supreme Court Revives Disproportionate Assets Case, Says Tax Circulars on Gold Limits Can't Substitute Proof of Income Source
Supreme Court Revives Disproportionate Assets Case, Says Tax Circulars on Gold Limits Can't Substitute Proof of Income Source

The Supreme Court has ruled that circulars and press releases issued by tax authorities, which specify how much gold an individual may possess, cannot be used as a shield to explain away unaccounted wealth in corruption cases.

A bench comprising Justice KV Viswanathan and Justice Arun Palli held that possessing gold within limits set by such administrative instructions is a completely different matter from proving the legitimate source of funds used to acquire that gold.

The ruling came while setting aside an order of the Patna High Court, which had quashed criminal proceedings against a former Child Development Project Officer booked under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, for allegedly amassing assets disproportionate to her known income.

Background of the Dispute

The High Court had relied on two administrative documents — Instruction No. 1916 dated May 11, 1994, and a Press Release dated December 1, 2016, issued by the Ministry of Finance's Central Board of Direct Taxes — while quashing the case.

These documents prescribe permissible quantities of gold that can be held without question during income-tax searches: 500 grams for a married woman, 250 grams for an unmarried woman, and 100 grams for a male.

Since the gold jewellery recovered from the respondent and her unmarried daughter totalled 646.400 grams, which fell within the combined permissible threshold under these norms, the High Court concluded that the possession was lawful and that no prosecution could proceed.

State's Challenge Before the Apex Court

Aggrieved by this reasoning, the State approached the Supreme Court, arguing that these income-tax instructions were never meant to determine whether assets were disproportionate to a public servant's known sources of income under anti-corruption law.

According to the State, such circulars merely guide tax officials on when gold can be exempted from seizure during raids — they do not address the legal question of whether the person had legitimate means to acquire that gold in the first place.

Supreme Court's Findings

Agreeing with the State's position, the Bench found the High Court's approach fundamentally flawed.

The Court clarified that in a prosecution under Section 13(1)(e) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, the central issue is whether the accused can explain the disproportionality between their assets and known income.

It observed that merely demonstrating that the gold held falls within limits specified by press releases does not amount to accounting for how those assets were acquired.

The judgment drew a clear distinction between the permission to possess gold and the obligation to account for its source — holding that the two concepts cannot be conflated.

"Merely showing certain press release and circulars permitting the holding of gold to a certain extent will not amount to accounting for the possession of the said assets," the Court noted in its order.

Outcome

Accepting the State's appeal, the Supreme Court restored the corruption proceedings against the respondent, allowing the trial to proceed on the disproportionate assets allegations.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant: AOR Akshay Amritanshu- 3121, Adv. Sarthak Srivastava, Adv. Akshat Aggrawal, Adv. Utkarsh Rai, Adv. Jyotsna Shandilya, Adv. Atharve Tiwari
Counsel for Opposite Party: Adv. Ranjit Kumar, AOR Karan Verma- 4227, Adv. Shobhit Ahuja
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward