Aviation

Supreme Court Declines To Fast-Track Diwali Airfare Case, Tells Petitioner To Skip Flying

Supreme Court Declines To Fast-Track Diwali Airfare Case, Tells Petitioner To Skip Flying
Supreme Court Declines To Fast-Track Diwali Airfare Case, Tells Petitioner To Skip Flying

The Supreme Court on Monday turned down a request for urgent hearing of an application challenging sharp spikes in domestic airfares during the Diwali season, with Justice Vikram Nath remarking that the petitioner should simply avoid flying if fares were too high.

The application, which forms part of a larger pending public interest litigation on airline pricing practices, sought directions to the central government to devise a system for capping domestic airfares during festival periods, along with interim relief for the ongoing Diwali and upcoming year-end travel seasons.

When the matter was mentioned before a bench comprising Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta and Justice Aparesh Singh, advocate Abhinav, appearing for the petitioner, argued that airfares had surged to as much as 700% of normal levels and that such steep hikes amounted to a breach of Article 14 of the Constitution, given that air travel now functions as an essential service for many citizens.

The bench was unmoved. "Don't travel by air. Next case," Justice Nath told counsel, declining to grant an urgent listing.

Background Of The Case

The interlocutory application was brought by petitioner S. Laxminarayanan, who already has a writ petition pending before the top court challenging algorithm-driven dynamic pricing by airlines, abrupt last-minute fare hikes, and additional charges levied on passengers. That main petition is scheduled for hearing on 16 November 2026, pursuant to an earlier court order.

The fresh application, filed on October 30, asked the court to direct interim fare caps for the festive period and to restore the free checked baggage allowance in economy class from the current 15 kg back to 25 kg.

Significantly, this plea comes close on the heels of the Centre notifying the Bharatiya Vayuyan Niyam, 2026 on 1 November — a regulatory framework introduced after the Supreme Court had pushed for government action in the same PIL back in January 2026, when it took note of recurring price surges during festivals and peak travel windows. The new rules are set to come into force from 1 January 2027.

Under these rules, the central government retains authority to issue fare-related directions to airlines in extraordinary situations warranting public interest intervention. Rule 192 further requires scheduled airline operators to fix fares based on operational costs, among other factors, and to submit tariff particulars to the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA).

The Numbers Cited In The Plea

The petitioner's application laid out specific fare data to illustrate the scale of the price surge ahead of Diwali, drawing on a Hindustan news report dated October 29.

According to the plea, a Delhi-Kolkata ticket that usually costs between ₹10,000 and ₹11,000 had shot up to ₹78,694 for travel scheduled on 6 November.

The application also pointed to wide fare gaps between flights on identical routes on the same day. A Bengaluru-Delhi flight departing at 5 am on 6 November was priced around ₹15,901, while a flight on the same route later that day, at 3:45 pm, cost ₹40,506.

Similar disparities were flagged for the Mumbai-Delhi sector, where fares climbed from ₹11,531 to ₹60,577, and for Delhi-Mumbai flights, where prices rose from ₹5,223 to ₹26,793.

Fuel Cost Justification Rejected

The petitioner's application specifically challenged the standard explanation offered by airlines and echoed by the Union government — that elevated aviation turbine fuel (ATF) costs justify the fare hikes.

The plea argued this reasoning collapses under scrutiny since flights on the same route, on the same day, burn comparable amounts of fuel, yet show vastly different pricing. It noted that during a hearing on 13 July 2026, the Supreme Court itself had observed that airlines frequently attribute fare increases of 100% to 300% to fuel costs and geopolitical factors, even though fuel's actual share in overall cost is relatively modest.

"A rise in fuel cost may justify a marginal revision, never a fare of seven times the ordinary fare," the application stated, asserting that demand-driven, rather than cost-driven, pricing allows airlines to take advantage of travellers during high-demand periods such as festivals.

Relief Sought

The petitioner urged the court to direct the Union government and aviation regulators to design a mechanism specifically for capping domestic airfares during festival windows, and, until such a system is in place, to impose temporary ceilings on economy fares for the current Diwali season as well as the upcoming year-end holiday period.

The plea emphasised that the relief being sought was narrow and time-bound, arguing that airlines would still earn significantly above their operating costs even with a cap in place, whereas passengers who have already paid inflated fares — or abandoned travel plans altogether — have no avenue for redress. On this basis, it contended that the balance of convenience favoured granting the interim directions.

The application also pressed for restoration of the free baggage allowance to 25 kg, noting that festival travellers typically carry gifts and household items, and are currently forced to pay excess baggage charges on top of already inflated fares.

No Alternative To Air Travel, Plea Argues

The petitioner contended that confirmed railway tickets for festival dates get booked out well in advance, leaving air travel as the only viable option for people needing to travel for festivals, medical emergencies, bereavements, or job-related reasons.

Drawing comparisons with other regulated essential services, the plea pointed out that railway flexi-fares are capped at one-and-a-half times the base fare, that essential medicine prices are controlled under the Drugs (Prices Control) Order, 2013, and that electricity tariffs are fixed by regulatory commissions — arguing that air travel should not remain the sole unregulated exception despite its essential nature for many travellers.

Regulatory Powers Already Exist, Plea Says

The application further argued that the Centre and the DGCA already possess the legal tools to curb what it termed predatory pricing but have chosen not to act.

It pointed to Rule 135 of the Aircraft Rules, 1937, preserved under Section 43(2) of the Bhartiya Vayuyan Adhiniyam, 2024, which requires airline tariffs to reflect operational costs, a reasonable profit margin, and prevailing market rates, while also empowering the DGCA to act against excessive or predatory pricing.

The plea described the recurring, predictable nature of festival-season surges as comparable to the hardship caused by sudden travel disruptions, arguing that government inaction despite having clear regulatory authority amounts to permitting exploitation of passengers, in violation of Articles 14, 19(1)(d) and 21 of the Constitution.

Despite these arguments, the Supreme Court declined to advance the hearing date, leaving the matter to be taken up along with the main petition in November.

Case: S. Laxminarayanan v. Union of India
Counsel for Applicant: Adv. Abhinav
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward