Advocacy

Senior Advocate Flags Ethical Double Standards in Arbitration Practice

Senior Advocate Flags Ethical Double Standards in Arbitration Practice
Senior Advocate Flags Ethical Double Standards in Arbitration Practice

Lawyers frequently behave in ways during arbitration that they would never dare attempt in open court, Senior Advocate Aditya Sondhi said on Saturday, pointing to a troubling episode in which a panel of retired judges was reportedly pushed into stepping down from a sensitive defence-contract dispute.

"I think lawyers take many liberties in arbitrations which they would not in court," Sondhi remarked.

He was addressing a gathering at a conference titled Ethics and Evidence in Arbitration, held in Bengaluru, where he raised a pointed question about whether the public nature of court proceedings is what keeps advocates in check.

"Is it the fact that court hearings are in public? There is a bar watching you. There is Bar and Bench watching you. The public is watching you in a sense. Does that change the ethical approach of counsel to the proceedings, in contrast to arbitration, which is essentially a private confidential process?" he asked.

Sondhi made these remarks during a panel session moderated by Justice Anu Sivaraman of the Karnataka High Court. Joining him on the panel were Lomesh Kiran Nidumuri, Partner at Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas, and Manini Brar, Founder of Arbridge Chambers & Solicitors.

According to Sondhi, institutional arbitration frameworks often set tougher ethical benchmarks than standard litigation, especially on matters of confidentiality and non-interference. Yet, he noted, arbitral tribunals don't wield the same disciplinary authority that courts possess.

He floated the idea that enhancing transparency—such as publishing arbitral awards—might serve as a check on questionable conduct.

Sondhi then narrated an incident involving a defence-contract arbitration, where a bench of retired judges allegedly faced pressure to withdraw from the case after issuing an interim ruling in favour of a private entity. He said the tribunal itself had noted in its records that it was the conduct and tactics of counsel that forced the recusal.

Nidumuri echoed concerns about counsel overloading tribunals with excessive and often irrelevant material.

"I think the lawyers are also guilty of dumping loads and loads of material onto the tribunal, evidence that we know is not even relevant for the particular case. I think we have to hold ourselves accountable for it," he said.

He also flagged the issue of parties repeatedly appointing the same arbitrators, referencing a Delhi High Court matter that reportedly involved thousands of such repeat appointments.

Brar, meanwhile, drew a line between an arbitrator's failure to disclose potential conflicts and actual grounds for disqualification, cautioning that non-disclosure alone does not prove bias.

"You cannot propose the removal of an arbitrator simply because there has been nondisclosure. You must first assess the circumstances of the conflict," she said.

Justice Sivaraman weighed in, noting that parties opting for arbitration effectively surrender several procedural protections that courts typically guarantee, including the ability to revisit facts or contractual interpretations.

"When parties choose arbitration, they forego the protections that a traditional courtroom affords them. They also forego any re-examination on facts, interpretation of the contract, so on and so forth. This is more the reason why the integrity of the system must be preserved," she said.

A separate session focused on evidentiary standards was chaired by Justice Nerale Veerabhadraiah Bhavani of the Karnataka High Court, with Senior Advocate Dhyan Chinappa, arbitrator and counsel Poornima Hatti, and Hima Lawrence, Co-Founder of VH Law Chambers, as panellists.

Chinappa warned against the casual acceptance of unverified documents simply because arbitral proceedings aren't bound by formal rules of evidence. He described a construction-related arbitration where the opposing side submitted a photocopied bill allegedly bearing his client's signature.

When the tribunal admitted the document over his objections, Chinappa illustrated in real time how simple it was to forge such evidence—by swapping his client's signature with that of the presiding arbitrator. He lost that arbitration but later succeeded in getting the award overturned through a challenge under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.

"My biggest problem and my biggest concern is the fact that we may end up in a scenario where we allow documentary evidence to come on record without the existence or the reliability having been established," Chinappa said.

Hatti called for arbitral proceedings to establish clear evidentiary ground rules early on, and for greater openness about arbitrators' use of artificial intelligence tools.

Lawrence stressed the need for procedural fairness, particularly while cross-examining expert witnesses, stating, "Every party should be given an equal and good opportunity to meet the case that is built against or made against them."

The conference was jointly organised by the London Court of International Arbitration, ArbitralWomen, and the Arbitration and Conciliation Centre Bengaluru, and was held at the Karnataka Judicial Academy.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward