All High Courts

P&H HC Declines To Transfer DV Case To Family Court Over Maintenance

P&H HC Declines To Transfer DV Case To Family Court Over Maintenance
P&H HC Declines To Transfer DV Case To Family Court Over Maintenance

The Punjab and Haryana High Court has ruled that a wife's independent complaint under Section 12 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 cannot be shifted from a Judicial Magistrate to a Family Court simply because a maintenance case between the same spouses is already pending there.

Justice Mandeep Pannu dismissed the husband's plea for transfer, observing that the mere pendency of a maintenance petition before the Family Court does not hand that court jurisdiction over a separate proceeding filed under Section 12 of the DV Act. The judge said allowing such a transfer would effectively place the domestic violence case before a forum that the statutory scheme never intended to vest with original jurisdiction over it.

Background Of The Case

The wife's domestic violence complaint was pending before a Judicial Magistrate First Class in Gurugram. Simultaneously, a maintenance petition filed under Section 125 CrPC (now Section 144 BNSS) between the same parties was pending before the Family Court, Gurugram.

The husband moved an application seeking to transfer the DV case to the Family Court, invoking Section 24 of the CPC and Section 7 of the Family Courts Act, 1984.

Why The Husband Sought Transfer

The husband's case rested on the overlap between the two proceedings. He argued that the facts and evidence in both cases were substantially the same, and that trying them separately before two different courts risked multiplicity of litigation and potentially conflicting findings. He also pointed to Section 26 of the DV Act, which permits a Family Court to grant reliefs under Sections 18 to 22 of the Act, contending this showed the Family Court already had the power to deal with such claims.

Opposing the plea, Senior Advocate Kshitij Sharma, appearing for the wife, argued that the statute specifically designates the Magistrate's court as the forum for a Section 12 application. She submitted that Section 26 "has a limited scope and cannot be construed as conferring concurrent jurisdiction upon the Family Court," and that transferring the case would strip her of the procedural safeguards and appellate remedy available under the DV Act.

What The High Court Held

Examining the statutory framework, the Court noted that Section 27 of the DV Act names the Judicial Magistrate First Class or Metropolitan Magistrate as the competent authority for a Section 12 application, while Section 28 subjects such proceedings to the CrPC.

On Section 26, the Court drew a clear distinction between granting DV reliefs within an already pending case and acquiring jurisdiction to entertain a fresh, independent Section 12 application. It held that the provision only lets an aggrieved person seek specified reliefs in proceedings already before designated courts, and said "the power to grant certain reliefs under the Act in an already pending proceeding cannot automatically be equated with the jurisdiction to entertain and adjudicate an independent application instituted under Section 12 thereof."

The judgment relied on the Kerala High Court's Division Bench ruling in Vineet Ganesh v. Priyanka Vasan (2023) and the Delhi High Court's decision in Aseem Khanna, noting that the Delhi High Court had weighed both the Bombay and Kerala positions before declining to follow Rohan Shah.

The Court also referred to the Supreme Court's ruling in Shaurabh Kumar Tripathi, clarifying that it had dealt with whether a High Court could quash DV proceedings using inherent powers, not with transfer of cases. Even so, it found the Supreme Court's interpretation of Sections 26 and 27 "of considerable relevance to the controversy involved in the present case," adding that the civil character of DV proceedings does not change the forum the legislature has designated for a Section 12 application.

Family Courts Act No Help

The Court also turned down the husband's reliance on Section 7 of the Family Courts Act. It explained that Section 7(2)(a) only confers upon the Family Court the Magistrate's jurisdiction under Chapter IX of the CrPC, which concerns maintenance. Possessing that limited jurisdiction, the Court said, "does not mean that it thereby acquires jurisdiction to entertain every other proceeding between them, particularly one for which a separate forum has been prescribed under a special enactment."

Convenience Cannot Override Jurisdiction

Addressing the husband's concern about overlapping evidence and inconsistent outcomes, the Court held that such practical considerations "cannot override the statutory scheme governing the jurisdiction of the respective courts." It observed that the legislature had already built in a mechanism to avoid multiplicity through Section 26, which allows DV reliefs to be claimed within proceedings already pending before a Family Court.

The Court stressed that convenience, while relevant to deciding a transfer plea, cannot be the deciding factor when it would mean shifting a case to a forum without jurisdiction over it. "The jurisdiction of a court is conferred by statute and cannot be assumed merely on the basis of convenience or consent of the parties," the order stated.

With these findings, the High Court dismissed the husband's transfer application and directed both parties to appear before the Magistrate on the date already fixed for the domestic violence case.

Advocates Karan Kaushal and Nitesh Dalal appeared for the husband, while Senior Advocate Kshitij Sharma, assisted by Advocate Tamanna Banwala, represented the wife.

Case: Ashutosh Mittal Versus Punita Mittal
Counsel for Applicant: Adv. Karan Kaushal, Adv. Nitesh Dalal
Counsel for Opposite Party: Senior Adv. Kshitij Sharma, Adv. Tamanna Banwala
Order Date: 2026-11-12
Read Order:

Related Reads

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward