Madras High Court: Settlements Reached Post-Evidence Won't Entitle Litigants to Court Fee Refunds
Litigants who choose to settle their disputes privately after evidence has already been placed on record during trial cannot claim a refund of court fees, the Madras High Court has ruled, drawing a clear line on how far such refund benefits can be stretched.
The case, Susheela Kawar v. M Pettu Lakshmi, saw Justice PB Balaji reject the argument that a full refund must automatically follow whenever parties settle outside court, regardless of how far the trial had progressed.
"However, there is no doubt in my mind that a party is not entitled to any refund once evidence is recorded, if whatever little worth it may be," the judge observed in the October 30 ruling.
The dispute before the Court
The matter arose from two civil revision petitions filed against trial court orders that had denied litigants a complete refund of court fees despite their having resolved matters privately.
In one instance, the trial court allowed only a 50 per cent refund, after a 5 per cent deduction towards administrative costs. In the other, the request for any refund was turned down outright.
Petitioners' reliance on Supreme Court precedent
The petitioners leaned heavily on the Supreme Court's 2021 decision in High Court of Judicature at Madras v. MC Subramaniam, which had affirmed that parties settling disputes privately — even outside the formal ADR mechanisms under Section 89 of the Code of Civil Procedure — remained entitled to a full court fee refund.
Justice Balaji, however, found this precedent inapplicable to the facts at hand. He noted that the Supreme Court in that case had not examined either the procedural stage at which settlement occurred or the specific restrictions embedded in Section 69 of the Tamil Nadu Court Fees Act.
Reading down Section 69 and its amendment
According to the Court, Section 69 allows refunds only when settlement occurs before evidence is recorded on the substantive claims in the suit. While a 2017 legislative amendment raised the refundable quantum from 50 per cent to 100 per cent, lawmakers consciously preserved the pre-evidence cutoff.
Justice Balaji reasoned that this restriction exists because court fees are meant to offset the costs of running the judicial machinery — covering infrastructure, staff salaries, and the mechanics of conducting trials.
"Substantial judicial time and money has been consumed in the said process. This, in my considered view is why Section 69 still remains in the statute book, despite the introduction of Section 69-A and also subsequent amendment to the same by Act 6 of 2017," the Court stated.
Afcons principle invoked
Bolstering his reasoning, the judge cited the Supreme Court's earlier ruling in Afcons Infrastructure Ltd. v. Cherian Varkey Construction Pvt. Ltd., which had stressed that alternative dispute resolution ought ideally to be attempted before trial commences, not after substantial proceedings have taken place.
He pointed out that this Afcons reasoning was never placed before the Supreme Court bench that decided MC Subramaniam, which explained the apparent tension between the two rulings.
The High Court concluded that Section 69-A, which permits full refunds for out-of-court settlements, cannot be interpreted so broadly as to render Section 69 meaningless or obsolete.
Outcome of the petitions
Applying this framework, the Court sustained the trial court's refusal to grant a refund in the matter where evidence had already been recorded — including testimony from witnesses on both sides as well as a court witness.
Both civil revision petitions were consequently dismissed.
A call for legislative review
Beyond deciding the immediate dispute, the High Court flagged a broader policy concern and directed the Tamil Nadu State Law Commission to revisit whether Section 69-A, as it stands after the 2017 amendment, needs reconsideration.
The Court noted a troubling gap: under the existing provision, the full court fee becomes refundable the moment a case is referred to ADR — irrespective of whether that reference actually results in a settlement.
"There is no clarity or statutory provision or rule with regard to a situation where a reference to alternate dispute resolution fails and the parties are forced to come back to the court for trial. There is total silence with regard to whether the court fee which has already been refunded by then, would have to be repaid by the party, before proceeding with the trial of the case," the Court remarked.
To address this lacuna, the Court ordered that a copy of its judgment be sent to the Tamil Nadu Law Commission.
"A copy of this order shall be marked to the Tamil Nadu Law Commission to look into this grey area and see whether the provision as it stood prior to the substitution by Act 6 of 2017 would have to be restored, as it safeguarded the State Exchequer, by entitling the party to only a certificate for refund, with the refund actually taking place only if the dispute is settled and not otherwise," the Court added.
Tags
- News
- by-opportunities-desk
- Opportunities
- All High Courts
- Opportunities for Students
- Supreme Court of India
- by-nishtha
- Top Stories
- Job Openings
- Internships
- Criminal Law
- Delhi High Court
- by-tarun
- Constitutional Law
- Bail Matters
- Judiciary
- Governance
- Political
- Call for Papers
- Allahabad High Court
- Civil Procedure
- by-deepanshu
- by-neerav
- Kerala High Court
- Bombay High Court
- by-vivek
- Education
- by-utkarsh
- by-yash
- Advocacy
- Business
- Karnataka High Court
- Issues
- Matrimonial
- Media & Films
- Employment
- Moot Courts
- by-jasveer
- District Courts
- Jammu & Kashmir High Court
- Madras High Court
- Service Law
- by-anubhav
- Medical
- Public Interest / PIL
- by-ayush
- Transportation
- Tribunals & Authorities
- Banking & Finance
- Calcutta High Court
- Competitions
- Consumer
- Arbitration
- Environment
- Taxation
- Trademarks & Patents
- Advertising
- Money Laundering
- Electricity
- Gujarat High Court
- Land Acquisition
- Punjab & Haryana High Court
- Rajasthan High Court
- Aviation
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
- Meghalaya High Court
- Patna High Court
- Sports
- Articles
- Cyber Law & Data Protection
- Enviornment
- Events
- Gaming
- Himachal Pradesh High Court
- Insolvency & Bankruptcy
- National Company Law Appellate Tribunal
- Andhra Pradesh High Court
- Civil Law
- Jurisdiction
- Tripura High Court
- Uttarakhand High Court
- Central Consumer Protection Authority
- Chhattisgarh High Court
- Child Custody
- Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
- Finance
- Gauhati High Court
- Guahati High Court
- Insurance
- Jharkhand
- Jharkhand High Court
- Kerala
- Loans & Defaults
- Motor Accident Compensation
- NGOs
- National Green Tribunal
- Right To Information
- Sikkim High Court
- State Consumer Commissions
- Telangana High Court
Follow Nyaysha
Fresh legal updates across our platforms — follow wherever you already scroll.
LinkedInJudgments, appointments & career moves — for professionals Follow Instagram@nyaysha.in — visual explainers, reels & court-room snapshots Follow FacebookCommunity discussions & week-in-review roundups Follow TelegramLegal jobs, internships, moot courts, competitions, events & call for papers — instant alerts, first to know Join