Kerala HC Strikes Down Vizhinjam Erosion Panel Over Conflict-of-Interest Concerns, Orders Fresh Probe
In a significant setback for the Kerala government's handling of environmental complaints linked to the Vizhinjam International Deepwater Multipurpose Seaport, the Kerala High Court has struck down the constitution of an Expert Committee set up to probe claims of coastal erosion caused by the project, ruling that its formation was legally unsound.
Justice Harisankar V Menon, delivering the verdict on 30 October, held that the committee's findings — which concluded that the port had not caused any coastal erosion — cannot be relied upon by the state. The judgment has been reported as 2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 610.
The court has instructed the state government to set up a new, genuinely independent panel to re-examine the erosion allegations from scratch.
Background to the Dispute
The case stemmed from a writ petition filed by residents of fishing hamlets located within a 20-kilometre stretch north of Vizhinjam. These petitioners claimed that the port's breakwater structures had triggered serious erosion along the northern coastline while causing sand accretion to the south.
According to the petitioners, the construction work had devastated the shoreline, destroyed homes, and stripped away the livelihoods of traditional fishing communities, pushing many families into a state of existential crisis. Several residents, they said, had either lost their dwellings entirely or suffered major structural damage.
Their core grievance centred on an Expert Committee formed through a Government Order dated 6 October 2022, which had been issued in compliance with directions from the National Green Tribunal (NGT). The panel was headed by M.D. Kudale, a former Additional Director at the Central Water and Power Research Station (CWPRS), Pune, and was tasked with determining whether the port had caused coastal erosion and suggesting corrective measures.
The petitioners alleged that multiple members of this committee had prior professional ties to the port project or entities linked to its execution, compromising their neutrality. They requested that the court step in to form a fresh, genuinely independent panel under judicial oversight.
Arguments on Conflict of Interest
Senior advocate Prashant Bhushan, representing the petitioners, argued that the Kudale-led committee was structurally compromised from the outset.
A key point of contention was Kudale's earlier role as an expert in a Technical Sub-Committee connected to the Vizhinjam Seaport's development — a fact the petitioners said created an inherent conflict when he was later asked to assess the environmental fallout of the very same project.
The petitioners also flagged a striking contradiction between Kudale's past academic writing and the conclusions of the committee he later chaired. They cited his 2010 research paper, "Impact of Port Development on the Coastline and the Need for Protection," published in the Indian Journal of Geo-Marine Sciences. In that paper, Kudale had noted that port construction typically causes sediment buildup on the updrift side and erosion on the downdrift side — a finding seemingly at odds with his committee's later conclusion that no erosion had occurred.
Another committee member, Dr. P.V. Chandramohan, was accused of having served as President (Technical) at Navayuga Engineering Company Limited, a firm said to have business links to Adani Enterprises.
The petitioners additionally objected to the presence of Dr. Riji K. John on the panel, noting that his appointment as Vice Chancellor of the Kerala University of Fisheries and Ocean Studies (KUFOS) had previously been quashed by the court.
Further, they pointed out that the committee's fieldwork was minimal — just a single site visit on 23 May 2023, followed by a meeting with local residents the next day, before the final report was drafted.
State and Project Authorities' Defence
The state government countered that the erosion was the result of natural phenomena — high wave activity and cyclonic weather patterns along the western coastline — rather than any consequence of port construction.
It further argued that the project site lay between two rocky headlands, which naturally limited longshore sediment movement. The state also pointed to rehabilitation packages already extended to affected residents, noting that many petitioners had already availed of such benefits.
Vizhinjam International Seaport Limited, the sixth respondent, asserted that the project held strategic national significance and had cleared every required statutory hurdle. It argued that the environmental and Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) clearances had already been upheld by the NGT, and that the present petition was essentially an attempt to relitigate settled issues.
The project's concessionaire, the seventh respondent, similarly maintained that thorough environmental assessments had preceded the grant of all clearances.
Both respondents also raised a procedural objection, arguing that the petitioners had known about the alleged erosion since 2016 but waited until 2022 to approach the court — a delay they said should bar the petition.
Court Rejects Delay Argument
The High Court was unconvinced by the delay objection. It noted that the state itself had triggered the relevant timeline by issuing the Government Order of 6 October 2022 to form the Expert Committee in the first place.
Since the writ petition was directly tied to the constitution of this very committee and the process that followed, the court found no merit in blaming the petitioners for delay.
"This Court is of the opinion that in the light of the Government Order at Ext.P11 issued as above, the allegation of delay and laches raised by the respondents is only to be repelled," the court observed.
Scope of Judicial Review
Before delving into the merits, the court acknowledged settled legal principles governing judicial interference in large infrastructure projects, drawing on the Supreme Court's rulings in Union of India v. Kushala Shetty [(2011) 12 SCC 69] and National High Speed Rail Corporation Limited v. Montecarlo Limited [(2022) 6 SCC 401].
It reiterated that courts must exercise restraint in such matters, given the technical complexity and broader public interest typically involved.
However, the court clarified that this case did not require it to intervene in the actual execution of the Vizhinjam project. The petitioners had explicitly stated they were not seeking a halt to ongoing construction work.
The court therefore limited its inquiry strictly to whether the Expert Committee formed under the 6 October 2022 order was validly constituted, and whether its resulting report could be considered reliable.
Conflict of Interest Principles Applied
The court turned to established precedent on bias and conflict of interest, citing N.K. Bajpai v. Union of India [(2012) 4 SCC 653], which stresses the need to eliminate any overlap between personal interest and official responsibility.
It also referred to A.K. Kraipak v. Union of India [(1969) 2 SCC 262], where the Supreme Court held that the key test is whether there exist reasonable grounds to suspect bias, not whether bias is conclusively proven.
Applying these principles, the court found substantial merit in the petitioners' objections concerning Kudale's inclusion. It noted that his earlier role as an expert member of the Technical Sub-Committee for Vizhinjam Seaport's development was not disputed by any respondent.
"As already noticed, Sri. Kudale is stated to have been working as an expert member of the sub committee constituted for the development of Vizhinjam Seaport. If, as a matter of fact, he was so engaged, this Court is of the opinion that inclusion of Sri. Kudale in the Committee constituted pursuant to Ext.P11 Government Order ought to have been avoided," the court stated.
The court also examined the apparent contradiction between Kudale's 2010 academic findings — which acknowledged that breakwater construction and channel dredging could disrupt longshore sediment drift, causing accumulation on one side and erosion on the other — and the later committee report's conclusion that no such erosion had taken place.
While stopping short of ruling on the scientific merits of the committee's findings, the court said it was referencing Kudale's earlier published position only to assess the uncontroverted conflict-of-interest allegation.
"It is in stark contrast of the afore opinion, that the report of the Committee constituted pursuant to Ext.P11 Government Order has stated otherwise... this Court has made reference to the opinion of Sri. Kudale as above, contained in Ext.P5(a) only in the light of the uncontroverted allegation of conflict of interest raised by the petitioners herein," the court noted.
Regarding Dr. Chandramohan, the court observed that allegations about his professional ties to a company connected with the project concessionaire had not been properly rebutted by respondents six and seven, despite the sixth respondent's attempt at an explanation.
On the other hand, the court declined to disqualify Dr. Riji K. John, holding that the quashing of his appointment as KUFOS Vice-Chancellor, by itself, did not establish grounds for his removal from the Expert Committee.
NGT Monitoring Committee Argument Dismissed
The respondents had also pointed to a separate committee constituted under NGT directions to monitor shoreline changes through periodic reports, arguing that this rendered the disputed committee's findings largely redundant.
The petitioners pushed back, clarifying that the NGT-appointed body merely reviewed and validated reports produced by agencies hired by the project's concessionaire — it did not conduct an independent inquiry of its own.
The court sided with the petitioners on this point. It reasoned that since the state government had itself chosen to set up a dedicated committee via the October 2022 order specifically to probe erosion complaints, it could not now argue that this committee's findings were dispensable simply because another monitoring body existed.
The existence of the NGT-mandated panel, the court held, could not be used as a shield to overlook the structural flaws in the composition of the state's own Expert Committee.
Final Verdict and Directions
Taking into account the prior professional entanglements of certain committee members, the limited scope of the site inspection, and the circumstances surrounding the report's preparation, the court concluded that the committee's independence was seriously compromised.
The High Court consequently allowed the writ petition, declaring the constitution of the Expert Committee to be flawed and ruling that its final report cannot be acted upon by the state.
The state government has been directed to constitute a fresh, independent Expert Committee to carry out the studies originally envisaged under the October 2022 order, this time ensuring that none of its members carry any conflict of interest.
The court further instructed that the new committee be formed only after the government takes into account the observations made in this judgment, along with the concerns of the stakeholders involved in the dispute.
Tags
- News
- by-opportunities-desk
- Opportunities
- All High Courts
- Opportunities for Students
- Supreme Court of India
- by-nishtha
- Top Stories
- Job Openings
- Internships
- Criminal Law
- Delhi High Court
- by-tarun
- Constitutional Law
- Bail Matters
- Judiciary
- Governance
- Political
- Call for Papers
- Allahabad High Court
- Civil Procedure
- by-deepanshu
- by-neerav
- Kerala High Court
- Bombay High Court
- by-vivek
- Education
- by-utkarsh
- by-yash
- Advocacy
- Business
- Karnataka High Court
- Issues
- Matrimonial
- Media & Films
- Employment
- Moot Courts
- by-jasveer
- District Courts
- Jammu & Kashmir High Court
- Madras High Court
- Service Law
- by-anubhav
- Medical
- Public Interest / PIL
- by-ayush
- Transportation
- Tribunals & Authorities
- Banking & Finance
- Calcutta High Court
- Competitions
- Consumer
- Arbitration
- Environment
- Taxation
- Trademarks & Patents
- Advertising
- Money Laundering
- Electricity
- Gujarat High Court
- Land Acquisition
- Punjab & Haryana High Court
- Rajasthan High Court
- Aviation
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
- Meghalaya High Court
- Patna High Court
- Sports
- Articles
- Cyber Law & Data Protection
- Enviornment
- Events
- Gaming
- Himachal Pradesh High Court
- Insolvency & Bankruptcy
- National Company Law Appellate Tribunal
- Andhra Pradesh High Court
- Civil Law
- Jurisdiction
- Tripura High Court
- Uttarakhand High Court
- Central Consumer Protection Authority
- Chhattisgarh High Court
- Child Custody
- Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
- Finance
- Gauhati High Court
- Guahati High Court
- Insurance
- Jharkhand
- Jharkhand High Court
- Kerala
- Loans & Defaults
- Motor Accident Compensation
- NGOs
- National Green Tribunal
- Right To Information
- Sikkim High Court
- State Consumer Commissions
- Telangana High Court
Follow Nyaysha
Fresh legal updates across our platforms — follow wherever you already scroll.
LinkedInJudgments, appointments & career moves — for professionals Follow Instagram@nyaysha.in — visual explainers, reels & court-room snapshots Follow FacebookCommunity discussions & week-in-review roundups Follow TelegramLegal jobs, internships, moot courts, competitions, events & call for papers — instant alerts, first to know Join