All High Courts

Kerala High Court Presses Advocate Over Contempt Plea Against Trial Judge in Actress Assault Case

Kerala High Court Presses Advocate Over Contempt Plea Against Trial Judge in Actress Assault Case
Kerala High Court Presses Advocate Over Contempt Plea Against Trial Judge in Actress Assault Case

The Kerala High Court on Wednesday grappled with a procedural conundrum while hearing a contempt petition filed by Advocate T.B. Mini, questioning how it could possibly strike down remarks attributed to a trial judge if those remarks never made it into the official judicial record.

Mini, who represented the survivor in the high-profile 2017 Actress Assault Case, has accused trial judge Honey M. Varghese of branding her an "absent lawyer" who attended court for fewer than ten days during the trial. The advocate strongly disputes this characterisation, asserting she was present on more than 200 days of proceedings.

During the hearing, Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan probed the fundamental basis of the plea, asking pointedly whether the disputed comments were ever part of the judicial proceedings. "Is it part of the judicial proceedings? From where should I expunge the remarks if it is not there?" the judge remarked.

Appearing for Mini, counsel argued that the advocate had endured significant psychological distress and damage to her professional reputation over the past ten months, largely due to the alleged remarks and the media attention that followed. It was contended that the resulting publicity had hurt her standing in the profession and even her right to earn a livelihood, with sections of the public reportedly urging that she not be briefed in future matters.

The petitioner's side further questioned the appropriateness of a presiding judicial officer making such observations in front of media personnel, stressing that judges are expected to maintain restraint while performing their duties. Counsel also invoked Section 16 of the Contempt of Courts Act in support of the plea.

Among the reliefs sought were directions addressing the alleged remarks, removal of related media coverage, and measures to safeguard the petitioner's professional image. It was argued that the observations attributed to the judge had no bearing on the adjudication of the case in which they were supposedly made and were extraneous to the judicial function.

The Bench, however, repeatedly returned to the threshold question of whether the remarks genuinely formed part of the judicial record or the proceedings themselves. It also raised doubts about what remedy could be granted if the core complaint actually pertained to media houses that had published the reports but were not even arrayed as parties in the writ petition.

Justice Kunhikrishnan suggested that grievances against press coverage might be better addressed elsewhere. "If this is against media publication, you should approach the Press Council of India," the Court observed.

In response, counsel clarified that the complaint against media outlets was only incidental, with the primary grievance being directed at the conduct of the judicial officer concerned. It was reiterated that the petitioner had suffered serious personal and professional fallout, including reputational harm and self-imposed social withdrawal.

The petitioner's counsel also invoked established principles governing judicial observations, including whether a party's conduct was relevant to the proceedings, whether the observation was backed by evidence on record, and whether it was truly necessary for deciding the case.

Despite the legal uncertainties, the Court sought to offer the advocate some comfort regarding her professional reputation. "Convey to your client that this Court has full faith in her as a lawyer. This Court knows her capacity... I am sure that all the judges in this High Court know her capacity... She need not worry," Justice Kunhikrishnan said.

The matter has been listed for further hearing on Friday.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward