All High Courts

High Court Says Kannada Pleadings Valid Before Administrative Tribunal, Quashes Rejection Order

High Court Says Kannada Pleadings Valid Before Administrative Tribunal, Quashes Rejection Order
High Court Says Kannada Pleadings Valid Before Administrative Tribunal, Quashes Rejection Order

The Karnataka High Court has ruled that litigants are entitled to submit pleadings, including applications, in Kannada before the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal (KAT), overturning a tribunal order that had refused to accept such a filing.

The decision came in Suryakanth v. KPSC, where a Division Bench comprising Justice Ashok S Kinagi and Justice Subramanya Rangarao set aside a June 2025 order passed by the KAT rejecting an application filed in Kannada by the petitioner, Suryakanth.

The core issue before the Court was whether Rule 9(iii) of the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal Rules of Practice, 1990 covered applications within its scope of "pleadings." This rule explicitly allows pleadings and other documents to be submitted either in English or Kannada.

The Bench concluded that applications indeed fall under this definition, meaning there is no absolute bar preventing litigants from filing applications in Kannada before the tribunal.

In its October 7 order, the Court observed that parties retain the right to file applications in Kannada under Rule 9(iii) of the 1990 Rules. It further noted that the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 1986 grant the Bench discretion to permit Kannada during proceedings, though the final order must still be rendered in English.

The dispute originated when Suryakanth sought the KAT's permission to submit his original application in Kannada. The tribunal turned down this request, citing Rule 3 of the 1986 Rules, which designates English as the tribunal's official language.

Challenging this refusal, Suryakanth moved the High Court, arguing that Rule 3 itself permits document filing in Kannada and allows the Bench discretion to use Kannada during hearings, provided the final order is issued in English.

The State government contested this interpretation, maintaining that all pleadings before the Tribunal must be presented exclusively in English.

Examining both rule sets, the High Court found that Rule 3 of the 1986 Rules does allow parties to file documents in Kannada and empowers the tribunal to permit Kannada usage during proceedings, while mandating that final orders be in English.

The Bench also pointed to Rule 9(iii) of the 1990 Rules, which requires that all pleadings, affidavits, memoranda, document lists, and other papers submitted to the Tribunal be typewritten in either English or Kannada.

"As such, the petitioner has rightly filed the application in Kannada language in terms of clause (iii) of Rule 9 of Rules of 1990," the Court stated in its ruling.

The judges held that the tribunal had erred by overlooking this crucial provision under the 1990 Rules when it rejected the petitioner's application.

"Such a basic aspect was not properly considered by the Tribunal and committed an error in passing the impugned order," the Bench remarked.

Consequently, the High Court allowed the petition, quashed the tribunal's order, and granted the petitioner's interlocutory application seeking permission to file pleadings in Kannada. The original application was restored, with the tribunal directed to dispose of it in accordance with law.

Advocate Shankar Kattimani represented the petitioner in the matter.

Case: Suryakanth v. KPSC
Counsel for Applicant: Adv. Shankar Kattimani
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: 2026-10-07
Read Order:

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward