Advocacy

Karnataka HC Takes Suo Motu Contempt Action Against Lawyers Over Chief Justice's Courtroom Disruption

Karnataka HC Takes Suo Motu Contempt Action Against Lawyers Over Chief Justice's Courtroom Disruption
Karnataka HC Takes Suo Motu Contempt Action Against Lawyers Over Chief Justice's Courtroom Disruption

The Karnataka High Court on Tuesday launched suo motu contempt proceedings against unidentified advocates who allegedly stormed into the Chief Justice's courtroom and caused a disturbance during a state-wide protest organised by the Advocates Association of Bengaluru (AAB).

The protest, called to demand stricter enforcement of the Prohibition of Violence Against Advocates Act, 2023, had been organised jointly by the Karnataka State Bar Council, AAB, and other advocate bodies across the state following a spate of attacks on lawyers in various districts.

However, the demonstration took an unexpected turn when a group of advocates reportedly entered the Chief Justice's court hall and disrupted ongoing proceedings, prompting the court to act immediately.

A Division Bench comprising Chief Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice KS Hemalekha came down heavily on the advocates' conduct, calling it unacceptable for members of a profession meant to uphold the dignity of courts.

"Prima facie, we are of the view that this conduct amounts to contemptuous behaviour," the Bench recorded in its order.

The court has instructed its registry to scrutinise CCTV footage from the court hall to identify those responsible for the disturbance. It also ordered that notice be issued to AAB, directing the association to participate in the contempt proceedings.

The case will next be taken up on November 19.

Soon after the contempt order was passed, AAB treasurer Shwetha Ravishankar appeared before the Bench in an attempt to clarify the circumstances surrounding the incident.

The judges made clear they did not expect lawyers to force their way into a courtroom and cause chaos. Ravishankar explained that the hall had been crowded at the time, and that one individual who had approached the judges' dais had allegedly been shoved from behind by others.

The Bench was unmoved by this explanation, noting that regardless of the circumstances, the person had reached the dais itself.

"No, no. He came up right here. He came up to the dais. We have already issued a contempt notice. We are done. We are identifying the people who were here. This is not an acceptable behaviour that we will accept," the court remarked.

Referring to earlier Supreme Court rulings on lawyers' strikes and contempt action against bar association office-bearers, the Bench said it had been left with no alternative but to proceed against those involved.

"We have no option. We are constrained to initiate these proceedings," the judges observed.

When Ravishankar attempted to offer an apology on behalf of the advocates present, the Bench insisted that a mere verbal apology would not suffice and that a formal affidavit would be required instead.

"What apology? You will give an affidavit of apology if you want to do it. What kind of behaviour is this? You are an advocate? You are an officer of the Court. You can't simply throw your responsibilities away and behave like this. It's absolutely unbecoming of an advocate," the Bench said sharply.

The judges went further, cautioning that beyond contempt action, the matter could also be forwarded to the Bar Council for additional disciplinary scrutiny.

"Not only will we issue contempt, we will refer it to the Bar Council," the court stated.

Addressing one advocate specifically implicated in the disruption, the Bench made a pointed remark about professional conduct: "There is no reason for you to be an advocate at all if you can't conduct yourself like an advocate."

Ravishankar then requested that the matter be given time, assuring the court that AAB's office-bearers would appear in person the following day and submit a formal affidavit on the association's behalf.

The Bench, however, held firm, stating that since contempt notice had already been formally issued, the association was obligated to respond through the proper process.

"We have given the notice in a contempt proceeding. You have to come and answer to this. This is contempt in the face of the court. File your reply, we will see what needs to be done," it said.

Expressing particular disappointment, the judges pointed out that they had earlier assured protesting lawyers that no adverse orders would be passed against them simply for staying away from court that day in solidarity with the protest.

"Personally speaking, this is not the kind of behaviour, especially after we have said that no adverse orders will be passed. We have told the Association, we understand your concern... This is still the High Court of the State, and if you think that anyone can barge in and start creating a ruckus, then the consequences must follow," the Bench said.

The court has directed AAB to submit its affidavit before the next hearing and indicated it would determine further steps only after hearing all parties concerned.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward