All High Courts

Karnataka HC: Slip of Tongue, Not Sedition — Court Drops Case Over 'Pakistan Zindabad' Slogan at BJP Protest

Karnataka HC: Slip of Tongue, Not Sedition — Court Drops Case Over 'Pakistan Zindabad' Slogan at BJP Protest
Karnataka HC: Slip of Tongue, Not Sedition — Court Drops Case Over 'Pakistan Zindabad' Slogan at BJP Protest

The Karnataka High Court has set aside criminal proceedings against a man who was accused of shouting "Pakistan Zindabad" during a demonstration organised by the Bharatiya Janata Party, reasoning that such a slogan being deliberately raised at a BJP event defies logic.

In a judgment delivered on October 28, Justice V Srishananda remarked that it would be improbable for attendees at a rally organised by a political party like the BJP to intentionally chant a slogan celebrating Pakistan. The case is titled DS Ravi Kumar v. State of Karnataka.

The judge accepted the petitioner's explanation that the phrase "Pakistan Zindabad" (long live Pakistan) had slipped out accidentally in place of the intended chant, "Pakistan Murdabad" (death to Pakistan), amid the heat of sloganeering.

"The argument of the petitioner needs to be considered that in the flow of raising the slogans by mistake the words Zindabad has crept in instead of Murdhabad," the Court noted, going on to hold that allowing the prosecution to continue would serve no purpose other than misusing legal process.

Background of the dispute

The matter stemmed from a petition moved by DS Ravi Kumar, who sought quashing of a criminal case lodged against him before a trial court in Mandya.

The FIR had been registered in 2024 by the Mandya West Police, invoking Section 153B of the Indian Penal Code — which deals with statements prejudicial to national integration — along with Section 505(1)(b), concerning public mischief.

According to the complaint, filed by one Kannambadi Kumar, a protest linked to BJP supporters had taken place on December 18, 2022. The complainant stated that he came across a video of the event showing participants raising the slogan "Pakistan Zindabad," which left him mentally disturbed, prompting him to approach the police.

Arguments before the Court

Representing Ravi Kumar, counsel argued that the utterance was accidental and lacked any intent to stir communal or public disorder. It was submitted that the correct slogan being chanted was "Pakistan Murdabad," and that the words were garbled only momentarily during the protest.

The defence maintained there was no design to target any community or disturb peace, and that prosecuting the petitioner over an inadvertent verbal slip was excessive.

The State, representing the prosecution, pushed back, asserting that the video evidence submitted by the complainant clearly captured the words "Pakistan Zindabad" being raised. It was pointed out that the protest itself had been triggered by a controversial remark allegedly made by Pakistan's Foreign Minister on the same date, December 18, 2022.

The prosecution's case was that Ravi Kumar had consciously raised the slogan with an intention to provoke unrest, and therefore deserved to face trial on merits.

Case: DS Ravi Kumar v. State of Karntaka
Counsel for Applicant: Adv. Vinod Kumar M
Counsel for Opposite Party: Adv. High Court Government Pleader Waheeda MM
Order Date: 2026-10-28
Read Order:

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward