All High Courts

Calcutta HC Upholds Death Sentence For Hooghly Child Rape-Murder

Calcutta HC Upholds Death Sentence For Hooghly Child Rape-Murder
Calcutta HC Upholds Death Sentence For Hooghly Child Rape-Murder

The Calcutta High Court has confirmed the death sentence given to Ashok Singh for the rape and murder of a five-year-old girl in Hooghly district in November 2024, turning down his challenge to both the conviction and the punishment.

A Division Bench of Justice Arijit Banerjee and Justice Apurba Sinha Ray delivered the verdict on November 17, affirming the capital punishment that the Exclusive POCSO Court in Chinsurah had handed down in January 2025.

Alongside confirming the sentence, the Bench pulled up the West Bengal Government for failing to pay the victim's family the compensation it had earlier been ordered to disburse, and raised the amount from Rs. 10 lakh to Rs. 15 lakh.

The Court acted on the State's death reference, DR 2 of 2025, and simultaneously dismissed Singh's criminal appeal, CRA (DB) 328 of 2025, against his conviction.

The Crime And Investigation In Hooghly

According to the prosecution, Singh and the victim's family lived in the same locality. On November 24, 2024, the girl — around five years and ten months old — went missing from home.

During a search by her parents and neighbours, she was discovered inside Singh's house, lying unconscious on a blanket under a mosquito net. She was found naked and bleeding from her private parts, with her clothes strewn nearby.

She was rushed to Dhaniakhali Rural Hospital, where doctors declared her dead.

A neighbour testified that she had witnessed Singh luring the child into his home with the promise of chocolates. Forensic reports corroborated this account, detecting Singh's DNA in swabs taken from the victim's genital area.

The post-mortem findings pointed to forceful penetration of both the vagina and anus, along with severe head injuries. The examining doctor attributed the death to intracranial haemorrhage linked to the forceful penetration, concluding that the death was homicidal in nature.

Relying on this evidence, the trial court convicted Singh under relevant provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, and the POCSO Act, 2012, sentencing him to death for rape and murder.

Arguments Before The Calcutta High Court

Singh's counsel argued before the High Court that the case rested purely on circumstantial evidence and that the prosecution had not built an unbroken chain of circumstances pointing solely to his guilt.

The defence specifically attacked the credibility of the neighbour-witness, noting that she had not mentioned seeing Singh take the child away either to the police or before the Magistrate during the investigation stage.

It was further contended that the trial court had rushed to impose death without adequately weighing mitigating factors — including the possibility of reform, rehabilitation, or the option of life imprisonment for the remainder of Singh's natural life.

The State countered that the chain of circumstances was complete: the victim was last seen in Singh's company, her body was recovered from his room, and forensic and medical evidence firmly established his guilt.

The High Court examined the sentencing framework laid down by the Supreme Court in Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab and the line of decisions that followed it, reiterating that even in cases falling within the "rarest of rare" category, courts must assess whether the convict is capable of reform before awarding death.

After weighing both the circumstances of the offence and of the offender, the Bench found no infirmity in the trial court's findings and upheld the conviction and sentence in full.

Why The Court Rejected Reformation Possibility

In deciding whether Singh could be reformed, the Bench reviewed his medical and psychological evaluations along with a report filed by the Probation Officer.

The judgment noted that Singh, roughly 45 years old, is illiterate and currently has no family. His medical assessments showed no signs of mental illness or psychological disorder that could explain or mitigate his conduct.

The Court also took into account statements by two prosecution witnesses recorded before the Magistrate, alleging that Singh had behaved inappropriately with other minor girls in the neighbourhood in the past.

It observed that Singh displayed no remorse during his examination under Section 313 CrPC, even when confronted with forensic evidence directly linking him to the crime.

The Bench remarked that his attitude revealed a deep-seated criminal mindset, observing that he appeared to believe he had done nothing wrong to the child, despite the fact that she had been raped, murdered, and his semen found on her body.

Based on this, the Court concluded there was no possibility of reformation.

The judges also took note of the emotional toll on the victim's parents, recording that her mother had broken down and even fainted at one point while testifying during the trial.

Weighing this anguish against the brutality of the crime, the Bench held that there was no legal or factual basis to interfere with the trial court's judgment and sentence, and confirmed the death penalty accordingly.

Compensation Directive To West Bengal Government

A significant part of the ruling dealt with the State's failure to pay the victim's family the compensation previously ordered.

The Court expressed concern that the parents had not received even the original Rs. 10 lakh compensation amount, despite the State actively seeking the death penalty for the accused in the same case.

Calling this contradiction "unfortunate," the Bench enhanced the compensation to Rs. 15 lakh and directed the State to release the amount within two months.

It further ordered that a compliance report on the payment be submitted by January 30, 2027.

What Happens Next

The High Court directed the Registrar General to forward a copy of the judgment to Singh through the Superintendent of the correctional home where he is lodged, informing him of his right to appeal before the Supreme Court and to avail free legal aid for the same.

With the death reference confirmed and his criminal appeal dismissed, Singh's only recourse now lies in approaching the Supreme Court against the High Court's order.

Case: State of West Bengal v. Ashok Singh*, DR 2 of 2025 with CRA (DB) 328 of 2025.
Counsel for Applicant: Adv. Amit Ranjan Pati, Adv. Swastika Chowdhury, Adv. Ilika Nag, Adv. Yavik Singhal, Adv. Avijit Chatterjee.
Counsel for Opposite Party: Adv. Jayanta Narayan Chatterjee, Spl. PP, Adv. Santanu Talukdar, Adv. Moumita Pandit, Adv. Supreme Naskar, Adv. Ritushree Banerjee, Adv. Kaushik Gupta, Sr. Advocate, Adv. Apalak Basu.
Order Date: 2026-11-17
Read Order:

Related Reads

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward