All High Courts

IVF Failure Alone Cannot Trigger Cheating Charges Against Doctors, Rules Allahabad High Court

IVF Failure Alone Cannot Trigger Cheating Charges Against Doctors, Rules Allahabad High Court
IVF Failure Alone Cannot Trigger Cheating Charges Against Doctors, Rules Allahabad High Court

The Allahabad High Court has ruled that an unsuccessful IVF procedure cannot, by itself, be treated as proof of fraud or form the basis for prosecuting a doctor under Section 420 IPC.

Justice Chawan Prakash, presiding over the matter, drew a sharp line between a case of medical failure or contractual breach and genuine criminal cheating, noting that everything hinges on whether the accused possessed dishonest intent at the time patients were induced to part with their money.

The judge observed that promising IVF treatment is fundamentally different from promising a guaranteed pregnancy, since fertility procedures carry built-in failure rates shaped by a host of physiological variables beyond anyone's control.

Acting on these findings, the Court quashed the criminal case pending against a woman fertility specialist who had moved the High Court seeking to set aside a magistrate's order directing her to stand trial under Section 420 IPC.

Background of the Dispute

The case originated from a complaint lodged by one Jaiveer Singh, who claimed his wife had remained unable to conceive since their wedding, prompting the couple to seek treatment from Dr. Teotia, the applicant before the Court, at Teotia Hospital and Fertility Centre in Bulandshahr.

Singh alleged that the doctor assured him she could help his wife conceive through IVF and asked for ₹3.5 lakh, which he paid across several installments. He further claimed that despite this payment, the doctor issued him a receipt for only ₹1.6 lakh.

When the treatment failed and his wife did not become pregnant, Singh said he sought a refund, but the doctor allegedly kept delaying and eventually declined outright, reportedly telling him, "This is how we make money: by misleading people. We have connections in high places."

Singh claimed that local police failed to act on his grievance, which led him to approach the trial court under Section 156(3) CrPC. The magistrate subsequently recorded his statement under Section 200 CrPC, along with statements from his wife and another witness under Section 202 CrPC, before issuing summons against the doctor under Section 420 IPC.

The doctor then challenged these proceedings before the High Court.

Arguments Raised

Representing herself before the Court, the applicant-doctor argued that no medical procedure—least of all IVF—comes with an assured outcome. She contended that a failed IVF attempt could not, therefore, be interpreted as evidence that she harbored dishonest intentions from the very beginning of the transaction.

The complainant and the State, on the other hand, maintained that the magistrate had appropriately formed a prima facie view based on the statements gathered under Sections 200 and 202 CrPC, and that the summoning order was legally sound.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward