Advocacy

Allahabad High Court Moves to Prosecute Lawyers Over Courtroom Rampage, Seeks FIR Against Perpetrators

Allahabad High Court Moves to Prosecute Lawyers Over Courtroom Rampage, Seeks FIR Against Perpetrators
Allahabad High Court Moves to Prosecute Lawyers Over Courtroom Rampage, Seeks FIR Against Perpetrators

The Allahabad High Court has concluded that lawyers who allegedly thrashed state law officers, court staff and security personnel while ransacking a courtroom constitute a case of criminal contempt, setting in motion formal proceedings against those involved in the October 28 melee.

In a significant order, the Court has also urged the Chief Justice to direct police action against the advocates implicated in the violence, as well as against individuals who spread misleading accounts of the episode on social media.

A Division Bench comprising Justice Ajay Bhanot and Justice Divesh Chandra Samant held that the conduct of the lawyers amounted to scandalizing the institution, disrupting judicial work and obstructing the administration of justice.

The judges noted pointedly that appeasement cannot pacify violence — only bringing wrongdoers to book and reinforcing the deterrent force of law can check such conduct.

Given these findings, the Bench ruled that criminal contempt proceedings were warranted against the lawyers concerned and ordered the matter to be placed before the Chief Justice, who may then assign it to an appropriate Bench for prosecution in accordance with law.

The Court further requested that the Registrar General be directed to ensure FIRs are lodged against the advocates allegedly responsible for inciting violence, conspiring to commit violence, carrying out the assault, and vandalizing court property — along with any other offences disclosed by the facts.

Significantly, the FIR directive also extends to those who posted fabricated or distorted accounts of the October 27 and 28 incidents on social media, with the Court suggesting such content be taken down and blocked.

Background to the Suo Motu Proceedings

The order stems from a suo motu case initiated after chaos erupted in Court No. 49 on October 28, when a group of advocates allegedly stormed in, disrupted ongoing hearings, and turned violent against Additional Government Advocates (AGAs), court staff and security personnel.

According to the Bench's account, trouble was brewing even before the judges entered the courtroom that morning. As Justice Bhanot and Justice Samant prepared to step out from chambers, they were alerted that an unruly crowd of lawyers had gathered inside, raising slogans.

Senior Advocate VP Srivastava appeared before the Court to set the record straight, stating unequivocally that no incident involving his humiliation had occurred during proceedings the previous day, October 27. He affirmed that the courtroom atmosphere had been cordial throughout his presence.

Despite his clarification, the commotion from other lawyers escalated to a point where judicial proceedings became untenable, forcing the Bench to rise.

Assault on Law Officers

The situation worsened after the judges withdrew to their chambers. AGA-I Paritosh Kumar Malviya subsequently approached them visibly shaken — his face swollen and his gait unsteady from injury.

He narrated that once the Court had risen, a group of advocates set upon him violently inside the courtroom itself, threatening him specifically for representing the State in proceedings.

Corroborating accounts followed from fellow AGAs Sanjeev Pandey, Pradeep Jaiswar and Sandeep Tiwari, who told the Bench they too had been assaulted and intimidated during the same episode.

The Bench examined the Registrar General's report alongside statements from the affected law officers before arriving at its findings.

Based on this material, the Court recorded that lawyers had hurled abuses, raised provocative slogans, physically attacked State counsel and court personnel, and engaged in outright violence and destruction of property during working hours of the Court.

Courtroom furniture was found damaged and overturned, and security staff present at the scene were also assaulted in the process.

The Disputed Bar Association Letter

The Court's order also scrutinized a letter dated October 27, issued by Dr. CP Upadhyay, Senior Advocate and President-elect of the Allahabad High Court Bar Association, along with Santosh Kumar Mishra, Advocate and General Secretary-elect.

The letter had threatened a boycott of Justice Bhanot's court, alleging that he had humiliated an advocate during proceedings and mocked a senior counsel in open court.

Addressed to the Chief Justice through the Registrar General, the communication from the incoming Bar office-bearers sought action over the alleged conduct in Justice Bhanot's courtroom.

However, the Bench found these allegations to be factually unfounded. It pointed out that Senior Advocate Srivastava — the very person said to have been humiliated — had personally appeared and denied that any such incident took place.

The Court also clarified that no order had been passed directing imprisonment of any advocate, contrary to what the letter had claimed.

It observed critically that the Bar Association's newly elected representatives had issued the letter without first verifying facts with the Court.

Bar-Bench Relations and Free Speech

Touching on the broader relationship between the Bar and Bench, the judges emphasized that dialogue between the two must be rooted in mutual respect, and that disagreements should never be allowed to spiral into violence or coercion.

In a striking observation, the Bench remarked: "Anarchy is not a species of dissent. Freedom of speech at the Bar is not the freedom to slander the Bench."

The Court noted that the legal system possesses well-established mechanisms for debate and discourse between lawyers and judges, but these traditions leave no space for intimidation or violent conduct. Incitement to violence, it held, falls outside the bounds of legitimate legal discourse and instead constitutes criminal wrongdoing.

Concerns Over Social Media Misinformation

The Bench also flagged the spread of misleading and incomplete narratives on social media platforms following the incident, cautioning that such content risked generating public disaffection toward the High Court and interfering with judicial functioning.

The Registrar General's report dated October 28 has been ordered to be preserved in a sealed cover.

Closing its order, the Bench commended Senior Advocate VP Srivastava and the AGAs who came forward to recount events, describing them as having "stood on the burning deck to tell the truth and to uphold the process of this Court."

Case:
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward