Advocacy

Allahabad Bar Writes to Oudh Bar Association Seeking Action Against Justice Deshwal Amid Escalating Bar-Bench Row

Allahabad Bar Writes to Oudh Bar Association Seeking Action Against Justice Deshwal Amid Escalating Bar-Bench Row
Allahabad Bar Writes to Oudh Bar Association Seeking Action Against Justice Deshwal Amid Escalating Bar-Bench Row

The simmering discord between lawyers and judges at the Allahabad High Court has taken a fresh turn, with the Allahabad High Court Bar Association (HCBA) formally approaching the Oudh Bar Association for support in its campaign against Justice Arun Kumar Singh Deshwal.

In a communication dated October 31, 2026, addressed to the newly elected President and General Secretary of the Oudh Bar Association, the HCBA raised objections to two orders passed by Justice Deshwal on October 28 and 29, 2026. The Association claimed these orders damaged the standing and dignity of the legal fraternity.

According to the letter, lawyers responded to the two orders with protests strong enough to prevent Justice Deshwal from conducting proceedings in his courtroom on both days.

The correspondence explicitly asks the Oudh Bar's new leadership to undertake "समुचित कार्यवाही" — appropriate action — to keep the judge away from judicial work, calling for a unified response from the legal community.

The orders in question arose in two separate bail matters: Devendra Kumar v. State of U.P. (Bail Application No. 32917 of 2026), decided on October 28, and Ankit Singh alias Anant Singh v. State of U.P. (Bail Application No. 36572 of 2026), decided on October 29.

The HCBA was particularly critical of the second order, alleging it was designed to sow discord within the Bar's ranks — a move it termed "condemnable." It maintained that both orders had harmed the interests and public image of advocates.

Senior Advocate Dr. C.P. Upadhyay, the newly elected HCBA President, along with General Secretary Santosh Kumar Mishra, signed the letter on behalf of the Association.

The Backdrop: Fallout From the Justice Bhanot Episode

The controversy traces back to an October 27 incident in the courtroom of Justice Ajay Bhanot, where the HCBA alleged that the judge had humiliated a practising advocate and made mocking remarks against a senior counsel. The allegation triggered widespread protests by lawyers at the High Court premises.

It was against this backdrop that Justice Deshwal passed his two contested orders.

What the October 28 and 29 Orders Said

In the Devendra Kumar matter, Justice Deshwal's October 28 order directed that advocates who had allegedly shouted slogans and disrupted proceedings in the court corridors — as part of the protest over the Justice Bhanot incident — be identified.

The order recorded that certain lawyers had raised their voices outside the courtroom in a manner that interfered with ongoing judicial work. Justice Deshwal termed this conduct "absolutely contemptuous" and suggested that the matter be forwarded to the Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh for disciplinary action, while also flagging the possibility of initiating contempt proceedings.

A day later, in the Ankit Singh alias Anant Singh case, the judge dealt with complaints that certain individuals claiming to be High Court advocates had blocked other lawyers from entering his courtroom to argue their cases. Justice Deshwal asked the newly constituted Bar Association leadership to examine the matter and ensure the Court's dignity was upheld.

It is these two orders — and their implications for the conduct of advocates — that the HCBA has flagged in its letter to the Oudh Bar, seeking collective intervention.

A Further Order on October 30: Judge's Appeal to Young Lawyers

In a related development, Justice Deshwal passed another order on October 30, 2026, voicing unease over the continuing disruptions and the growing rift between the Bar and the Bench.

In this order, passed while hearing a bail application, the judge noted that counsel for the applicant could not appear because certain advocates had forcibly prevented lawyers from entering the courtroom. The order also recorded that Government Advocates had been physically removed from the courtroom.

Justice Deshwal further noted that he had personally heard a woman advocate crying out as she tried to enter the courtroom for her case, alleging she was misbehaved with and forcibly kept out.

Calling such behaviour damaging to the reputation of both the Bar and the Bench, the judge made pointed observations about the responsibilities of advocates, especially younger members of the profession.

He advised young lawyers to devote their energy to studying and preparing their cases rather than pursuing popularity on social media, reminding them that they represent the High Court's future — as tomorrow's senior advocates and judges.

The Court also stated it was taking "judicial notice" of social media posts by young advocates relating to the functioning of the High Court. It warned that circulating partial or distorted information without careful thought risked an "unnecessary accentuation of differences between the Bar and the Bench."

Justice Deshwal reiterated that lawyers enjoy public respect primarily because of the trust citizens place in the High Court, and stressed that preserving the institution's dignity was a shared responsibility of both judges and advocates — not the burden of the judiciary alone.

He also clarified that this obligation to uphold dignity extended to Government Advocates as well, since they too form part of the Bar.

The judge expressed hope that the newly elected office-bearers of the Allahabad High Court Bar Association would take the matter seriously and adopt suitable measures to safeguard the High Court's standing.

Standoff Continues

With the HCBA now formally seeking the Oudh Bar Association's backing to restrain Justice Deshwal from judicial work, and the judge himself urging restraint and introspection within the Bar, the episode marks one of the more pointed confrontations between lawyers and the judiciary at the Allahabad High Court in recent months. How the Oudh Bar responds to the HCBA's appeal, and whether the newly elected leadership of either association takes concrete steps, remains to be seen.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward