by-nishtha

Shinde Faction Tells Supreme Court Disqualification Case Against Its MLAs Has Lost Purpose With Assembly's Term Over

Shinde Faction Tells Supreme Court Disqualification Case Against Its MLAs Has Lost Purpose With Assembly's Term Over
supreme-court-shinde-faction-disqualification-case-assembly-term-over
Shinde Faction Tells Supreme Court Disqualification Case Against Its MLAs Has Lost Purpose With Assembly's Term Over

The Supreme Court on Thursday heard extensive arguments from the Eknath Shinde camp in the long-running Shiv Sena split case, with senior counsel contending that the plea seeking disqualification of Shinde faction legislators no longer serves any practical purpose since the 14th Maharashtra Legislative Assembly has already completed its term.

Senior Advocate Dhruv Mehta, appearing for the Shinde faction, told a bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V Mohana that the Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray group's challenge against the Speaker's refusal to disqualify the breakaway MLAs under the Tenth Schedule has become infructuous.

The matter arose from a petition by Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Sunil Prabhu, who had questioned the Maharashtra Assembly Speaker's decision not to disqualify the Shinde camp legislators under the anti-defection law. A connected petition by Uddhav Thackeray, challenging the Election Commission of India's verdict granting the Shinde faction official Shiv Sena status and the "bow and arrow" symbol, was also taken up by the bench.

Assembly Term Expiry Central To Infructuousness Argument

Mehta's core submission was straightforward: once the Assembly's tenure lapses under Article 172 of the Constitution, the respondents automatically cease to hold membership, leaving the Court with no scope to grant any meaningful relief by way of disqualification from that very Assembly.

He pointed out that the Thackeray camp was still pressing for a formal declaration that the Shinde MLAs stood disqualified under the Tenth Schedule, reasoning that such a finding would retroactively apply to the original acts of defection. This, Mehta explained, was aimed at undercutting the legislative majority the ECI had relied upon while recognising the Shinde faction, thereby indirectly attacking the Commission's decision itself.

However, Mehta argued this line of reasoning was legally untenable, since the Speaker's authority under the Tenth Schedule is strictly limited to adjudicating disqualification petitions against sitting members of the House.

Speaker's Powers Are Binary, Says Mehta

Invoking the Constitution Bench ruling in Kihoto Hollohan v. Zachillhu, Mehta emphasised that the Speaker functions as a tribunal under the Tenth Schedule, and this jurisdiction cannot extend to issuing a disqualification declaration against someone who has already ceased to be a member.

"What is the power of the Speaker? The power of the Speaker is to either accept the petition and disqualify or reject the petition. There is no third power given to the Speaker under the Tenth Schedule," Mehta submitted before the bench.

He further contended that the Supreme Court's own powers under Article 136 cannot travel beyond what the Speaker was originally empowered to decide. Citing Kihoto Hollohan, he reminded the Court that judicial review of a Speaker's ruling is confined to narrow grounds — violation of constitutional mandate, breach of natural justice, perversity, and mala fides.

"If the source did not have the power, in exercise of review jurisdiction, do you have such a power?" Mehta posed to the bench, questioning whether the Court could assume an authority the Speaker never possessed.

Remand, Not Adjudication, Is The Usual Remedy

Mehta told the Court that where a Speaker's ruling is found legally flawed, the conventional remedy is to send the matter back to the Speaker for fresh consideration, relying on the precedent set in Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra.

He sought to distinguish the case from Rajendra Singh Rana v. Swami Prasad Maurya, where the Supreme Court had itself ruled on disqualification instead of remanding the matter, since a remand at that time would have been rendered meaningless given how close the Assembly was to dissolution. Mehta argued the present situation was different, as it involved the natural, operation-of-law expiry of the Assembly's five-year term rather than any urgency necessitating direct adjudication by the Court.

He also referred to the Tenth Schedule alongside the Maharashtra Legislative Assembly Members (Disqualification on Ground of Defection) Rules, 1986, asserting that such proceedings are inherently tied to sitting members, and sought to distinguish this case from precedents involving legislators who resign strategically to dodge disqualification proceedings.

ECI's Legislative Majority Test Was Justified, Argues Singh

Senior Advocate Maninder Singh, also representing the Shinde faction, defended the Election Commission's approach of relying on legislative strength rather than organisational structure to determine the "real" Shiv Sena.

Singh argued that political parties registered under Section 29A of the Representation of the People Act are obligated to maintain internal democratic practices through organisational elections. According to him, when office-bearers are merely nominated instead of being elected, the organisational-majority test loses credibility and cannot be mechanically applied to resolve such disputes.

Drawing comparisons to the ECI's past decisions involving the Nationalist Congress Party and the Telugu Desam Party, Singh contended that an organisational majority cannot be given decisive weight when the underlying structure itself lacks democratic sanctity. He also invoked the "breaking down of the rule" principle discussed in O.P. Singla.

Singh submitted that repeated postponement of internal elections or reliance on nominated ad hoc committees effectively nullifies any majority test based on such bodies.

He cited Paragraphs 6A, 6B, and 6C of the Election Symbols (Reservation and Allotment) Order, concerning recognition of parties based on poll performance, and argued that the internal democracy requirement under Section 29A(5) was directly relevant to the Commission exercising powers under Paragraph 15 of the Symbols Order, which deals with disputes between rival factions within a party.

Singh clarified that the ECI was never approached to deregister the Shiv Sena or to rule on a broader dispute concerning its internal elections — the organisational framework was only relevant insofar as it helped determine which test should guide resolution of the factional dispute.

He additionally urged the Court not to reopen the symbol allocation issue indefinitely, pointing out that both factions had already contested several elections using the symbols assigned by the ECI, and voters had cast their ballots accordingly.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party: Senior Adv. Dhruv Mehta, Senior Adv. Maninder Singh
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward