by-nishtha

Kerala Congress Unit Tenders Unconditional Apology to CJI Surya Kant Over Controversial Social Media Post

Kerala Congress Unit Tenders Unconditional Apology to CJI Surya Kant Over Controversial Social Media Post
Kerala Congress Unit Tenders Unconditional Apology to CJI Surya Kant Over Controversial Social Media Post

The Kerala Pradesh Congress Committee (KPCC) has formally apologised to Chief Justice of India Surya Kant following a contentious post shared on the official X handle of the Indian National Congress Kerala unit. According to the party, the post went up without proper authorisation, and the individual behind it, Vijay Thottathil, has since been stripped of his position.

The apology came in response to a legal notice issued by Advocate Meneesh Dubey, who serves as Joint Secretary of the Supreme Court Bar Association. Replying on behalf of the KPCC, party president Sunny Joseph offered an unconditional apology to the Chief Justice, acknowledging the disrespectful tone of the language used in the post. Joseph also confirmed that Thottathil has been directed to issue a public apology of his own.

At the centre of the row is a post from October 12 that called for the CJI's resignation and hinted that the party would seek a replacement for him. The post was taken down shortly after it triggered widespread criticism, but not before drawing sharp attention to the party's social media conduct.

In his written response, Joseph explained that Thottathil had put out the post independently, without any prior clearance, discussion or sign-off from the KPCC's leadership. He stressed that neither he nor any senior party functionary had sanctioned the call for the CJI's resignation or the suggestion about finding a successor.

"The expressions reproduced in your notice do not represent the policy, considered opinion or authorised position of the KPCC and that of the Indian National Congress," the reply stated.

The party leadership made clear that it disapproved of the content and had formally disowned and withdrawn the remarks. It characterised the resignation demand and talk of a replacement as improper, adding that such language had no place on an official party account.

Joseph went further to underline the party's institutional stance, stating, "The KPCC unequivocally reaffirms its respect for the Constitution, the independence of the judiciary and the constitutional office of the Chief Justice of India."

At the same time, the committee conceded that the episode had exposed gaps in how it monitors its digital platforms, even as it maintained that the post was never cleared by anyone in authority.

The KPCC indicated it would now review the protocols governing access to its social media handles, including who is authorised to operate them and what approval steps are required before any official content is published.

This review, the party said, would look into how the post was drafted, vetted and finally posted, identify everyone involved in the process, and examine account permissions, devices used, and any earlier instructions or internal correspondence that may be relevant.

The committee also committed to safeguarding all pertinent digital evidence—including access logs, approval trails and internal communications—clarifying that simply deleting the post from public view would not amount to erasing records needed for any formal inquiry.

It further noted that engaging an outside agency to handle its digital communications does not absolve the party of the responsibility to maintain proper internal checks.

While distinguishing between legitimate criticism of judicial rulings and language that erodes the dignity expected of public discourse, the KPCC asserted that political differences could never justify the kind of language used in the deleted post.

The party's reply also rejected any implication that Sunny Joseph had personally approved, directed or endorsed the post. Nonetheless, it admitted the need to scrutinise the breakdown in its communication oversight and to put safeguards in place to avoid a repeat occurrence.

Advocate Dubey's original notice had sought several disclosures from the KPCC president—namely, the identity and role of whoever wrote and uploaded the post, details of anyone who may have approved it, reasons for the delay in issuing a public apology to the CJI, and specifics of any disciplinary action taken against the responsible individual beyond his removal from office.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: NA
Read Order: Not Uploaded Yet

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward