Advocacy

Karnataka HC Scraps Assault, Molestation Case Against Lawyer After Woman Retracts Allegations in Later Statement

Karnataka HC Scraps Assault, Molestation Case Against Lawyer After Woman Retracts Allegations in Later Statement
Karnataka HC Scraps Assault, Molestation Case Against Lawyer After Woman Retracts Allegations in Later Statement

The Karnataka High Court's Dharwad Bench has set aside criminal proceedings initiated against an advocate who faced accusations of physically assaulting a woman and outraging her modesty, after it emerged that the complainant herself had walked back her claims during the course of the police probe.

Justice T Venkatesh Naik, delivering the order on September 25, allowed the lawyer's plea to quash the case that had been lodged against him back in 2021. A key factor weighing on the Court's decision was a subsequent statement the woman gave to the investigating officer, wherein she clearly stated that the advocate never laid hands on her nor did anything that could be construed as outraging her modesty.

The dispute traces back to a complaint the woman filed in 2021, in which she alleged that the advocate had beaten her, hurled abuses at her, insulted her deliberately, and even threatened to kill her.

As per the prosecution's narrative, the woman had first engaged the advocate's professional services for a divorce case she had filed before the Family Court in Bengaluru. Over time, the two grew close and an intimate relationship developed between them.

Matters allegedly came to a head during the COVID-19 lockdown, when the woman traveled to the advocate's native village and introduced herself as his wife. This apparently triggered a heated argument, during which she accused him of assaulting her and issuing threats.

Acting on her complaint dated June 30, 2021, police at Hanumasagar in Koppal District registered an FIR and launched an investigation. Once the probe concluded, a chargesheet was filed against the advocate invoking Section 324 IPC (voluntarily causing hurt by dangerous weapons or means) and Section 354 IPC (assault or criminal force against a woman with intent to outrage her modesty).

Aggrieved, the advocate moved the High Court seeking to have the entire case thrown out.

Arguing on his behalf, counsel pointed to glaring inconsistencies and gaps in the complainant's account. It was submitted that while she had made specific accusations in her original complaint, she had entirely reversed her position in a subsequent statement recorded by the investigating officer.

The State, defending the prosecution, maintained that the chargesheet contained sufficient material pointing to the commission of the alleged offences, and argued that the veracity of these claims ought to be tested only through a complete trial rather than being short-circuited at this stage.

The High Court, however, concluded that the basic elements required to constitute offences under Sections 324 and 354 IPC were simply missing from the evidence placed before it. Notably, a wound certificate on record showed no injuries whatsoever on the complainant, casting serious doubt over the allegation that she had been hurt using dangerous weapons or means as required under Section 324.

On the Section 354 charge, the Court emphasized that proving such an offence hinges on establishing the accused's culpable intent. It found no material suggesting that the advocate's alleged actions were driven by any intention to sexually assault or outrage the complainant's modesty.

Given this lack of foundational evidence, coupled with the complainant's own retraction of her earlier allegations, the Court ruled that permitting the criminal case to proceed further would serve no purpose.

"The FIR lodged by respondent No.2 is without any probable cause," the Bench observed in its order.

It additionally held that allowing the prosecution to continue under these circumstances would amount to nothing short of an abuse of the process of law.

With these findings, the High Court quashed the criminal proceedings in their entirety.

Advocate K L Patil represented the petitioner-advocate before the Court, while High Court Government Pleader Praveena Y Devareddiyavara appeared on behalf of the State. The complainant was represented by advocate Vidyashankar G Dalawai.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant: Adv. K L Patil
Counsel for Opposite Party: Adv. High Court Government Pleader Praveena Y Devareddiyavara
Order Date: 2026-09-25
Read Order:

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward