Arbitration

Karnataka Commercial Court Quashes ₹9-Crore Arbitral Award in School Maintenance Payment Dispute

Karnataka Commercial Court Quashes ₹9-Crore Arbitral Award in School Maintenance Payment Dispute
Karnataka Commercial Court Quashes ₹9-Crore Arbitral Award in School Maintenance Payment Dispute

A commercial court in Bengaluru has overturned an arbitral award that had directed the Karnataka Department of State Education Research and Training (DSERT) to pay more than ₹9 crore to IT services firm Puthur Infotech, ruling that the arbitrator ignored a crucial limitation defence raised by the State.

The case, DSERT v. Puthur Info, centred on a contract for maintaining UPS systems, printers and LCD projectors across 4,396 schools in Karnataka.

Judge Vijaya Kumar Rai, presiding over the commercial court, found that the arbitrator's failure to rule on whether the company's claims were time-barred amounted to patent illegality, describing it as a defect that struck at the very foundation of the award.

The dispute traces back to a 2013 tender floated by DSERT for upkeep of electronic equipment in 1,763 government high schools and 2,633 aided high schools statewide. Puthur Infotech won the contract, valued at ₹7.19 crore, covering the period from April 2014 to April 2015.

Although the department released ₹5.07 crore to the company, Puthur Infotech claimed the remaining dues were withheld despite the work being completed satisfactorily. It later moved the MSME Council, which referred the matter to arbitration after conciliation efforts collapsed.

In May 2023, sole arbitrator and former Chief Justice of the Himachal Pradesh High Court, L Narayana Swamy, ruled in the company's favour, granting ₹7.75 crore with interest along with a further ₹1.27 crore with interest. The arbitrator also dismissed a counterclaim by the government seeking ₹4.34 crore over alleged service shortfalls.

When the State contested the award, it pointed out that 16 of the 17 invoices forming the basis of the company's claim had already become time-barred by the time arbitration proceedings commenced in 2018.

The commercial court accepted this argument, observing that the dues under these invoices had fallen due more than three years before the company approached the MSME Council. It dismissed the company's plea that repeated assurances from government officials had the effect of extending the limitation period.

The court also faulted the arbitrator for dismissing the State's counterclaim solely on the ground that the department had not separately approached the MSME Council, clarifying that such a prerequisite was not mandatory for a buyer to raise a counterclaim during arbitration.

Since the original award had clubbed both the barred and potentially valid claims without distinguishing the amounts attributable to each, the court chose to set aside the award in its entirety.

Case: DESERT v. Puthur Info
Counsel for Applicant: Adv. Additional Adv. General Aditya Vikram Bhat
Counsel for Opposite Party: Adv. Adinath Narde, Adv. Revathy Adinath Narde
Order Date: 2026-10-01
Read Order:

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward