All High Courts

Consumer watchdog fines Delhi's Shangri-La Eros ₹1 lakh over mandatory-style service charges

Consumer watchdog fines Delhi's Shangri-La Eros ₹1 lakh over mandatory-style service charges
Consumer watchdog fines Delhi's Shangri-La Eros ₹1 lakh over mandatory-style service charges

The Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) has slapped a ₹1 lakh penalty on New Delhi's Shangri-La Eros hotel after finding that it continued charging customers a service fee on restaurant bills even though the Delhi High Court had already ruled such levies must be purely voluntary.

A bench comprising Chief Commissioner Nidhi Khare and Commissioner Anupam Mishra ruled that automatically tacking on service charges and expecting diners to seek their removal amounts to an unfair trade practice that tramples on consumer rights.

The authority made clear that labelling a charge as "optional" on paper means nothing if it is still baked into the bill by default. According to the CCPA, simply printing the word "service charge" on a menu or invoice does not erase the coercive effect of its automatic inclusion.

The October 22 order traces back to complaints lodged in May and June 2025 against Mister Chai, a restaurant operating inside the hotel, which allegedly tacked a 10 percent service charge onto food bills. These complaints triggered a preliminary inquiry and a subsequent probe by the CCPA's Director General (Investigation).

Investigators found concrete instances of the practice — a ₹435 service charge added to a ₹4,350 bill in May 2025, and a ₹125 charge on a ₹1,250 bill the following month. The probe concluded that such automatic additions gave customers the false impression that payment was mandatory.

In its defence, Shangri-La Eros insisted it never forced anyone to pay the charge, pointing out that its menu described the fee as discretionary and that patrons were free to decline or seek a refund. The hotel argued diners had ample chance to opt out before the final bill was settled.

During the hearings, the hotel revealed it had rebranded the fee as a "Charges for Voluntary Service Staff Contribution (Optional)". It also told the CCPA that it had completely stopped collecting any such charge across its outlets from October 1, 2026, and had refunded the amounts paid by the complainants.

The CCPA, however, was not persuaded. It rejected the argument that offering refunds or a waiver option legitimised the automatic levy in the first place.

The authority reasoned that a menu note allowing customers to request a waiver effectively functioned as an opt-out system, shifting the responsibility onto diners to actively resist payment. This, it said, undermined genuine and informed consent and exposed customers to awkward social pressure right at the billing counter.

The CCPA further noted that merely renaming the charge as a "voluntary staff contribution" did not fix the underlying problem, since it was still being added to bills without customer initiation. It pointed out that the hotel had kept up this practice for close to 15 months even after the Delhi High Court's ruling.

Based on these findings, the CCPA held that the hotel's conduct breached provisions of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, concerning consumer rights, misleading claims, and unfair trade practices.

The authority has now ordered Shangri-La Eros to stop adding any form of service charge automatically, regardless of how it is labelled. Alongside the ₹1 lakh fine, the hotel has been directed to file a compliance report within 15 days.

Case:
Counsel for Applicant:
Counsel for Opposite Party:
Order Date: 2026-10-22
Read Order:

Tags

WhatsApp Channel

Nyaysha on WhatsApp

Judgments, jobs and legal analysis — the day in law, delivered straight to your WhatsApp. One tap to follow, leave anytime.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Read our cookie policy.

X (Twitter)Post LinkedInPost TelegramSend FacebookShare WhatsAppForward